2004 Australian Grand Prix Review
By Pablo Elizalde, Spain
Atlas F1 News Editor
Sunday's Australian Grand Prix was not the exciting event everybody was hoping for to start the 2004 season. Ferrari and Michael Schumacher dominanted the weekend from start to finish, not giving a chance to their rivals. Atlas F1's Pablo Elizalde reviews the events and results of the first Grand Prix of the year
F1 supremo Bernie Ecclestone said the result of Saturday's qualifying - with both Ferraris clearly in front - was a "disaster" for the sport and that it was not what he had expected. Apparently, even Ecclestone himself can be fooled by the misleading signs of pre-season testing.
The Briton did not make any comments following Sunday's race, but it was not too hard to imagine his mood after Michael Schumacher and Ferrari romped to a 2002-style victory that led to an anti-climatic and unexpected start to the season which could have hardly been more different than what the winter expectations had promised. Apparently, however, no one had told Ferrari or Schumacher about them.
As misleading as testing times have always been, few would have bet on Ferrari lapping a second per lap quicker than anyone else come the Albert Park race. The end of the 2003 season showed that the Italian team's rivals - and especially Williams - were very close, if not on par with them, and that Michelin had the upper hand over Bridgestone in the tyre war. With that in mind, it was not surprising to sense the fear of a repeat of 2002 in the paddock after the end of the race.
"I think Ferrari could probably have lapped everybody if they had wanted to. That is my assumption," said Mercedes' motorsports boss Norbert Haug before leaving Australia. "I hope 2002 is not coming back."
The truth is that the cooler weather conditions in the race played into the hands of Ferrari and their Bridgestone tyres. Or at least that is what is to be believed if the Japanese tyre manufacturer continue the trend set in 2003, when the Michelins fared better in hotter conditions. The bad news for his rivals was that with some 40 degrees on track on Friday and Saturday, Schumacher was also untouchable.
Some people in the paddock, playing down the unpopular start to the year, suggested the 2003 Grand Prix would have looked much like Sunday's race had Ferrari not failed to react properly to the rain. And yet 2003 turned out to be one of the most exciting seasons in recent Formula One history. It is way too early to say that 2004 is not going to be the same, but the Australian Grand Prix certainly did not offer much reason to hope, and not only because of Ferrari's dominance.
In Melbourne there were two new rules which were coming under close scrutiny and which did not seem to deliver the anticipated results. The much-talked-about one-engine rule - at least in its current form, with the teams spending millions to regain the lost performance - is not likely to save Formula One any money. What's worse, perhaps, is that it has made Friday a pointless day, with teams refusing to put unnecessary mileage on their engines.
To illustrate the point, it is worth mentioning that Schumacher topped the times on Friday's first practice after completing four laps. The teams who need more running are the teams who can't afford to plug in millions and millions into their engine's development programmes, so unless the powers that be manage to reduce what the top teams spend, the one-engine rule is only going to benefit the richer squads. It is no coincidence that Minardi are running a lower specification engine than Jordan and Jaguar when they had the latest unit available to them. For more money, of course.
The other novelty in this year's rulebook was the double-session qualifying, which proved to be disastrous, and not only in Ecclestone's eyes. There seemed to be a unanimous agreement from teams, media and fans over how utterly boring qualifying had been. The first session in particular was a non-event for the fans, with the drivers lapping slow enough to secure the chance of a good run in the second session.
The men doing the driving were not too thrilled either. Schumacher politely admitted the new qualifying format was "not interesting"; others, rightly, pointed out that it adds more confusion to the already convoluted weave that F1 regulations have become lately; and Minardi boss Paul Stoddart even raised a safety concern, with his cars likely to have to complete their two flying laps within three minutes of each other all season. There will certainly not be lack of suggestions on how to improve qualifying when the team bosses meet again.
It is inevitable to think that qualifying would have not received so much criticism had Sunday's race provided a good show. But as it turned out, Schumacher and Rubens Barrichello were untouchable, making a mockery of all the pre-season suggestions that their Michelin-shod rivals were the ones to beat. Schumacher's response was topping the times of every session and leading every lap of the race.
Winter testing is always deceiving, but if more than one of Ferrari's rivals admitted to being shocked by their pace was maybe not because of the results of the winter preparations but because of the change in momentum following the end of 2003.
Williams, the hot favourites before the start of the season, were never a match for Ferrari, and had he not slowed down at the end, chances are Schumacher would have ended up lapping both Juan Pablo Montoya and Ralf Schumacher. Whether the cooler conditions justify the second per lap that both Williams drivers were losing to their Ferrari rivals only time will tell.
Of those with high expectations ahead of the first race of the year, only Renault and BAR were close to living up to the hype, and in both cases with only one of their cars. Fernando Alonso's lonely drive demonstrated the Spaniard will be one of the men to watch this season, and that Renault's decision to switch back to a traditional engine layout was the right one. Apart from Schumacher and Barrichello, Alonso was the man of the race, driving cooly and flawlessly to his fifth F1 podium.
BAR Honda, with Jenson Button, showed their winter form was no fluke, being on par with the Williams during the whole weekend. The true test will be matching the top teams' development throughout the year, but their prospects had never looked so positive before.
The opposite could be said about the McLaren team, who left Australia with little to show for after their MP4-19 proved neither fast nor reliable: Kimi Raikkonen became the first retirement of 2004. Considering the Mercedes-powered machine has been testing since November and it should, in theory, be the most developed of the current crop of cars, McLaren's form in Australia was far from encouraging.
Qualifying
For the second consecutive season, Formula One saw the introduction of a new qualifying format aimed at spicing up the show and giving the fans more value for their money. If last year's format was received with mixed emotions, this year's new double-run layout was heavily criticised right from the start.
Some, like Schumacher, were more diplomatic in their comments. The Ferrari driver said the format was not interesting, a comment likely to be repeated in Malaysia when if, going out first in the opening session, he manages to set the fastest time. It will mean the German will have to wait for around 1.5 hours before going out to complete his second run.
Others, however, were not so mild and said the new system was a "disaster", "stupid", "dangerous", or the worst thing they had ever seen. At best it was utterly boring for the fans, who had to wait for over 80 minutes to see the battle for pole position. Obviously the end result did not help, as Schumacher and Barrichello were out of everyone else's reach, but still few would bet on the new format leading a long life.
The Grid
1. Michael Schumacher
2. Rubens Barrichello
3. Juan Pablo Montoya
4. Jenson Button
5. Fernando Alonso
6. Mark Webber
7. Takuma Sato
8. Ralf Schumacher
9. Jarno Trulli
10. Kimi Raikkonen
11. Felipe Massa
12. David Coulthard
13. Cristiano da Matta
14. Giancarlo Fisichella
15. Nick Heidfeld
16. Giorgio Pantano
17. Zsolt Baumgartner
18. Olivier Panis
19. Christian Klien
20. Gianmaria Bruni
The Race
Two factors came under the spotlight on race day: the first one was, as usual, the weather, which fortunately for the Bridgestone runners turned cooler due to the clouds covering Melbourne. The second important factor to consider was the absence of launch control, banned this season, and which had made the life of Formula One drivers much easier in recent times.
As if nothing had changed since 2003, however, when the red lights went off the Renaults flew off the line. Alonso's start was especially spectacular, the Spaniard - much quicker than Montoya in the getaway - making a gutsy move and overtaking the Colombian by putting two wheels of his car on the grass. Montoya took the inside line in the hope of keeping third place behind the leading Ferraris at the first corner, but the Williams driver left his braking too late and ran wide, not only losing his battle with Alonso, but dropping down to seventh place.
Michael Schumacher and Barrichello had a perfectly clean start and no troubles to keep the lead. Alonso followed, with Button in fourth, Trulli in fifth, and Ralf and Montoya behind him. Webber had dropped down to eighth, while the McLaren drivers were outside the points, with Coulthard in 10th and Raikkonen in 11th.
Montoya, trying to find his way back to the top of the field, tried to pass a slower Trulli during the opening laps, but without success. The frustrated Colombian, who had made slight contact with his teammate Ralf while fighting for position, could do nothing to get ahead of the Italian while the leading Ferraris began to take off.
After five laps, Schumacher led Barrichello by two seconds, while Alonso, the only man who was able to stay relatively in touch with the Ferraris, was already five seconds behind. Button had already lost contact with the Renault.
The Sauber drivers were the first ones to produce some action in the race. Giancarlo Fisichella became the first driver to pit on lap nine, while only moments later, Felipe Massa showed McLaren's lack of pace by overtaking Raikkonen with a clean move at the first corner.
The Finn's race, however, would last only a few more meters as, with his rear wheels blocked due to an engine failure, he spun out of the race to become the first retirement of the year and, what's worse, to be the first victim of an engine failure. Raikkonen was not amused after his dismal start to the season.
"We were not expecting to qualifying in 10th and it is very disappointing. We should not be in that position. We should be fighting at the front," said Raikkonen.
This year's increased pitlane speed favoured more pitstops, and the Australian Grand Prix become a three-stopper for most of the field. Montoya, still stuck behind Trulli, was the first of the top runners to pit, on lap 10, while Barrichello followed on the next lap. Button, Alonso, Schumacher, Trulli and Ralf pitted on the following two laps, with only Coulthard staying out longer as McLaren opted for a different strategy.
After the first round of pitstops was over, Schumacher was leading Barrichello by less than two seconds and Alonso by almost 10. Button was fourth, albeit more than 20 seconds behind, with Ralf some three seconds behind after having passed both Trulli and Montoya in the pits. The Colombian, meanwhile, was still stuck behind the Renault driver.
The Ferraris continued dominating the race with ease as the action-less laps passed by: only a 360-degree spin by Massa on lap 19 altered the processional event as Schumacher and Barrichello extended their lead over Alonso as the second round of pitstops approached.
Montoya finally managed to overtake Trulli on lap 24, the Williams driver immediately showing the Italian was slowing him down badly. Montoya began to lap almost two seconds faster and dived into the pits moments later, only to lose time due to a problem with his car's right rear wheel. Fortunately for him he was able to stay ahead of Trulli.
All the drivers on a three-stop strategy completed their pitstops without problems, and the order in front remained unchanged, with Schumacher opening the gap to Barrichello, who was having problems with the brakes of his Ferrari F2004. By lap 35, the Brazilian trailed Schumacher by over seven seconds, while a lonely Alonso was already over half a minute behind. Ralf was running fourth over a minute adrift of his brother, while Button was under pressure from Montoya.
The Colombian finally managed to overtake the BAR driver on lap 38, in a move that saw Button having to run off the track at turn 13 as he fought to keep Montoya at bay. Apart from that, the on-track action was non-existent: the Ferraris continued to open up their gap to Alonso while Montoya began to close in on Ralf before the final round of pitstops was kicked off on lap 40.
First Alonso, and then the rest of the frontrunners completed their third pitstops. Only Nick Heidfeld brought some drama to the race when he overshot his braking point in the pitlane and ran into two of his mechanics as a result of a problem with his car. Fortunately both escaped injury, but the problem forced Heidfeld to retire only a few meters after leaving the pitlane.
With 10 laps remaining, Schumacher had opened a 22-second gap to Barrichello, as the World Champion looked set to lap Montoya. That was not to be, however, and the Ferrari driver decided to slow down and cruise for the remaining part of the race. Even so, Schumacher finished over a minute ahead of the Williams drivers in a clear demonstration of superiority that even surprised the German.
"After the last test at Imola and knowing the characteristics of this track, I was sure we would be competitive but I did not expect such a performance," said Schumacher, who finished ahead of Barrichello to give Ferrari their first one-two finish since Japan 2002.
Alonso completed the podium, while the Williams drivers had to settle for fourth and fifth, Ralf ahead of Montoya. Button kicked off his season with a promising sixth place ahead of Trulli. Coulthard took the final point, which was little consolation for the McLaren team after having finished over a lap behind Schumacher and his Ferrari.
The World Champion, however, was quick to play down his dominance.
"I am keeping my feet on the ground, because this race and the weather conditions suited us perhaps better than the others," he said. "We will have to wait and see what happens in Malaysia where it will be much hotter. I do not want to predict the season based on just one race."
Lap 1: At the start Michael Schumacher and Rubens Barrichello both get away well while Fernando Alonso jumps ahead of Jenson Button. At the first corner Barrichello lets Schumacher take the corner while Alonso slots into third as Montoya gets in a tangle and runs wide onto the grass. This drops the Colombian behind Button, Jarno Trulli, up from ninth on the grid, Ralf Schumacher. Mark Webber also loses out and ends the first lap in eighth place ahead of Takuma Sato, David Coulthard and Kimi Raikkonen. At the end of the lap Schumacher is a second clear of Barrichello.
Lap 2: Schumacher increases his lead by a 10th while those behind him begin to sort themselves out. Montoya passes his team mate Ralf Schumacher to grab back sixth place. Further back down the order, Nick Heidfeld passes Giancarlo Fisichella to grab 14th position and Gianmaria Bruni passes Giorgio Pantano to take 16th.
Lap 4: As the two Ferrari draw away, there is a battle for fifth place from the opposition, as Jarno Trulli tries to hold off the two Williams-BMWs. At the back Christian Klien moves ahead of Pantano to take 17th.
Lap 4: Schumacher's lead over Barrichello is nearly two seconds while the gap back to Alonso is already 2.8 seconds. At the back Klien passes Bruni for 16th.
Lap 8: The gap between the Ferraris is the same but they two cars have pulled five seconds ahead of Alonso. There is a gap back of more than 15 seconds to Button, Trulli, Montoya, Ralf Schumacher and Webber. Behind the Australian Sato is busy holding off the two McLarens for ninth place. At the back Giancarlo Fisichella is the first man to stop, having found himself stuck behind Nick Heidfeld's Jordan.
Lap 10: Montoya heads for pit lane to begin the major pit stops. Further back Kimi Raikkonen retires with a water pump failure, ending a very disappointing day for the McLaren team.
Lap 11: Barrichello, Alonso and Button all head for pit lane while further back Bruni comes in for his first stop.
Lap 12: The stops continue with Michael Schumacher, Trulli, Ralf Schumacher, Sato and Cristiano da Matta all stopping. When Schumacher rejoins he is only 1.5 seconds ahead of Barrichello, having dropped around a second to Barrichello. Alonso is third six seconds behind Barrichello.
Lap 13: Webber, running briefly in third place, comes into the pits for his first stop.
Lap 14: Coulthard and Massa both pit. Further down the order Heidfeld and Olivier Panis are also pit callers. It is not yet clear who is running to which strategies.
Lap 16: Klien comes in for his first pit stop, suggesting that he is running to a two-stop strategy. Further back Zsolt Baumgartner retires with a mechanical problem while Sato has a big off but manages to hold on to his position.
Lap 18: Michael Schumacher has some trouble with traffic and the gap to Barrichello drops to under a second but Alonso is still dropping back, the gap between Barrichello and the Renault driver now being up to eight seconds. Further back Pantano has his first stop, indicating that he is running to a two-stop strategy.
Lap 19: Massa has a high speed spin but keeps going in 11th place.
Lap 24: The order has not changed but Schumacher has built up his lead again to 2.9 seconds. Alonso comes in for his second stop and drops behind Button. Further back Montoya passes Trulli for sixth place. Down the field, Da Matta makes his second stop and drops from 13th to 15th.
Lap 26: Third-placed Button pits but his stop is slightly longer than normal because of a fuel nozzle problem. Montoya also pits and falls from sixth place to eighth.
Lap 27: The second stops continue with Webber pitting and falling from sixth place to 10th. Tenth-placed Sato also stops.
Lap 28: The stops carry on with Ralf Schumacher and Trulli stopping. Ralf is able to get out ahead of Button to take fourth place. Trulli rejoins behind Button and Montoya. Further back there are scheduled stops from Heidfeld and Fisichella, who have been fighting for 12th place.
Lap 29: Barrichello comes into the pits but when he rejoins in second place the car has a brake problem and he drops back quickly from Michael Schumacher.
Lap 30: Schumacher stops and rejoins in the lead, more than five seconds clear of Barrichello. Further back Webber slows and pits having lost sixth and seventh gears.
Lap 32: With all the second stops out of the way for those on three-stop strategies, the order is clear. Schumacher is pulling away from Barrichello but there is not much of a challenge from Alonso, who is over 20 seconds behind. He is followed by Ralf Schumacher, Button, Montoya, Trulli and Coulthard. Everyone else has been lapped.
Lap 33: Fisichella forces his way past Heidfeld to grab 12th place after a long battle.
Lap 36: Schumacher's lead is up to nine seconds but Alonso is still dropping back from Barrichello. In the midfield the two-stop runners Coulthard and Massa both pit. Coulthard stays ninth. Massa rejoins behind Sato in 10th.
Lap 37: Two stoppers Klien, Pantano and Panis all stop.
Lap 39: Montoya pushes his way past Button to grab fifth.
Lap 40: The final pit stops begin with Alonso stopping. He rejoins well ahead of fourth-placed Ralf Schumacher.
Lap 41: Trulli stops but he is still seventh when he rejoins.
Lap 42: Sixth-placed Button stops and holds onto the place but emerges a lap behind the leader. Down at the back Da Matta has his third stop.
Lap 44: Barrichello and Montoya complete their final stops but there is no change of order. Heidfeld stops on the track on his first lap after his pit stop. At the same time Massa's race ends with a mechanical problem. Fisichella completes his final pit stop in 10th place.
Lap 45: The two Schumacher brothers both pit (as does Sato) but all retain their positions for the run to the flag.
Lap 51: As Schumacher begins to back off, down at the back of the field Panis passes Pantano for 13th place.
Lap 54: Button un-laps himself as Schumacher eases off further, allowing Barrichello to close the gap between them.
Lap 58: Michael Schumacher wins his 71st Grand Prix victory – his fourth Australian GP victory – with Rubens Barrichello second and Fernando Alonso third. The remaining points go to Ralf Schumacher (4th), Juan Pablo Montoya (5th), Jenson Button (6th), Jarno Trulli (7th) and David Coulthard (8th). Takuma Sato is 9th and Giancarlo Fisichella 10th. Top rookie is Christian Klien in 11th place.
© 2007 autosport.com
. This service is provided under the Atlas F1 terms and conditions.
Please Contact Us for permission to republish this or any other material from Atlas F1. |