The 2004 Monaco GP Review
By Tom Keeble, USA
Atlas F1 Magazine Writer
There was no record for Michael Schumacher as Jarno Trulli surprised at the Monaco Grand Prix, scoring his maiden Formula One to put an end to the Ferrari driver's winning streak. The Monte Carlo race provided little wheel to wheel racing, yet it was still an event full of drama. Atlas F1's Tom Keeble reviews the entire weekend's event and results of the sixth round of the 2004 season
For Renault, it is vindication of their approach to the season, confirming their second position in the Championship, and importantly, ending the Ferrari and Bridgestone running streak. After waiting 117 races for this moment, Trulli said: "Everything was going through my mind. I have been waiting so long, I've been through a lot of bad moments and at the moment I just cannot realise that I won the race and I've won in Monaco, probably the best race in the world," before demonstrating the magnanimous spirit that makes him popular in the paddock: "I wish for myself and for Formula One that we have different winners in the future."
There is little doubt that he earned the win – even Schumacher said there was nothing he could have done, even if his race had run its course: "at best, I would have been second today. That was pretty much what we expected."
For Jenson Button, the race proved to be a long chase after the Renaults. He was running a similar strategy, but over a lap only had the same pace as Trulli, so there was never a real opportunity to pass. Whilst a relatively early first stop did offer the opportunity to move past Fernando Alonso, there was little chance of closing the gap to the leader. Furthermore, after Takuma Sato's engine had given up dramatically at the start of the race, there was concern that his would follow suit. Keeping Trulli honest led to Button and BAR-Honda's fourth podium of the year: they continue to look forward to a win, and on the evidence of this race, they have the potential to do it this year.
Ferrari's weekend, for a change, was not something to write home about. Even in Michael Schumacher's hands, the package was not good enough to make up for a relatively poor qualifying performance: Bridgestone's latest tyres did not really have the first lap performance to challenge Michelin, though they did look competitive over a full race distance.
In the event, it is not the competitiveness of the Ferrari package that is going to be the talking point of this weekend: the Williams drivers were not only involved in the only overtaking manoeuvres of the weekend, but they were also involved in the exits of Schumacher and Alonso.
First, Ralf Schumacher allowed Alonso to pass in the tunnel as he was being lapped, only for the young Renault driver to get on to the dirty part of the track, and lose control of his car. They differed in their views on the incident: "Ralf moved to the right and slowed down, I tried to overtake him but when we were side by side he went on the throttle again and pushed me into the barrier," was the Renault driver's opinion, whilst Schumacher says "He just ran into some dirt... I can understand his frustration but he went too far outside, ran into the dirt and then hit the wall."
Alonso's Renault exiting the tunnel in pieces caused the Safety Car to come out. At the end of the period, as Schumacher went into the tunnel, he stamped on his brakes to warm up the tyres and brakes, unfortunately catching the lapped Juan Pablo Montoya off guard. The Columbian took avoiding action, but the cars touched, pitching Schumacher into the wall and ending his race. Whether it was a mistake by the German to warm his brakes just after going into a dark tunnel, or by Montoya for failing to anticipate it is moot: the stewards dismissed the event.
The race itself raised some interesting issues. It is rare for the marshals at Monaco to face criticism, but questions could be raised after this event. Twice, marshals were to be seen standing well out on to the circuit as they waved yellow flags: they were looking to protect others who were cleaning up the track after incidents.
Whilst commendable, in both cases, there was a danger of serious injury as they were putting themselves into the paths of the cars that were attempting to get on with the racing. Furthermore, after Sato's engine expired in clouds of smoke, leading to the incident where the Fisichella's Sauber rode over the back of the David Coulthard's McLaren, ending upside-down against the Armco, one of the marshals reacted by waving the red flag, which should been a consequence and indication of the race being stopped.
On track, there were the normal complaints about the inconsistent application of blue flags, drivers who didn't get out of the way, or drivers who did unexpected things when they did move over. However, for the most part, the race was conducted in good grace, and provided a good spectacle for racing fans.
As always in Monaco, the qualifying session is absolutely vital to scoring well. The first session was made interesting by the degradation of the track since practice, which made it tricky for Michael Schumacher, as the first out. It ensured an unusual order for the main qualifying session.
The Grid
1. Jarno Trulli
2. Jenson Button
3. Fernando Alonso
4. Michael Schumacher
5. Kimi Raikkonen
6. Rubens Barrichello
7. Takuma Sato
8. David Coulthard
9. Juan Pablo Montoya
10. Giancarlo Fisichella
11. Mark Webber
12. Ralf Schumacher
13. Olivier Panis
14. Christian Klien
15. Cristiano da Matta
16. Felipe Massa
17. Nick Heidfeld
18. Giorgio Pantano
19. Zsolt Baumgartner
20. Gianmaria Bruni
The Race
Once the celebrities cleared the grid, Trulli led the pack on a very slow parade lap: this was clearly not good news for the Bridgestone runners, who struggle to get heat in to their tyres when they are new. The first start was aborted, even before the cars had returned to their slots, when Panis' car stalled.
The second parade lap was equally slow, but with Panis in the pitlane, when his clutch failed at the start, stalling the engine again, the remainder of the grid pulled away cleanly, and Panis joined at the end.
The start saw Alonso slip past Button into second, whilst Takuma Sato had a blinding start, squeezing Michael Schumacher and Kimi Raikkonen en route to leaping up to fourth place behind Button from seventh on the grid. Behind, Klien didn't complete a lap as he ran into Nick Heidfeld, knocking off his front wing before going off on a curb, but the remainder of the grid pulled away cleanly.
At the end of the first lap, Trulli led Alonso and Button, whilst Sato began to lose ground as the first symptoms of his engine giving way were manifesting themselves; he was holding up Raikkonen and the Ferraris. Behind, Coulthard was giving chase, and the remainder of the field followed in procession form.
Sato's adventure came to an abrupt end on lap five, just after the swimming pool, as his engine gave way in style. The ensuing mayhem saw Fisichella run into Coulthard in the smoke, turning his car upside down, and removing the Scot's rear wing. Both drivers' races were over. The Safety Car was deployed whilst the mess was being cleaned up, offering Heidfeld and Ralf Schumacher a reason to dive into the pits for fuel, dropping them near to the back of the field.
When the Safety Car pulled in, Montoya managed to pass Barrichello at the top of the hill, and things stayed as they were until the pitstops, except for Webber's Jaguar giving up and being dragged off the circuit.
Montoya was the first to stop, and rejoined behind Heidfeld. This looked like a tactical blunder from the Williams outfit, as the Columbian continued to lose substantial ground, lap after lap, behind the Jordan before finally squeezing past on lap 28, facing a minute deficit to the car in front: had his stop put him ahead, then he could possibly have fought for a podium.
At the front, Raikkonen's pace was sufficient to keep Michael Schumacher behind, but costs a few tenths a lap compared to the Renault's and Button's BAR. Button eventually pits from third on lap 18, rejoining in seventh ahead of da Matta – not to mention 20 seconds and three places in front of Montoya.
When Raikkonen pitted from third, Schumacher made the most of the clear air to start eating in to the Renault lead. When Barrichello stopped, he rejoined behind Massa, but the Sauber pitted shortly after. Schumacher brought the lead down under nine seconds before the Renaults pitted: when he finally made his stop, the Ferrari was ahead of Button's BAR, and only a handful of seconds behind the Renaults – though they were making the most of new rubber to ease the lead up again.
Raikkonen returned to the pits on lap 28, to retire: the team had spotted an issue in the telemetry, and didn't want to follow Honda's example.
On lap 38, Ralf Schumacher pits; he is rapidly running out of gears, which is effecting his pace. Shortly after, the Renault's came up to lap the Williams: Alonso made his move in the tunnel, and lost control on the marbles, wrecking the car on the wall. The Safety Car was immediately brought out, and a number of drivers took the opportunity to pit, including race leader Trulli, new second place man Button, Massa, da Matta and Montoya.
It proved a fateful stop for Montoya – first, because neither Ferrari stopped, so he discovered himself a lap down on the car ahead of him (Barrichello), yet lapping immediately behind Schumacher. On the last Safety Car lap, Schumacher was warming his tyres, and there was contact in the tunnel, pitching the German in to the wall – breaking off a front wheel, and ending his race.
On the restart, Trulli immediately opened up a six second lead over Button, whilst Barrichello was running a full lap ahead of fourth placed Montoya. There was some brief room to question whether the front runners had enough fuel to make the finish line, but part from Ralf Schumacher retiring with only fourth gear remaining, the order remained to the end.
As the cars lined up for the start Olivier Panis has a problem and the start is aborted with the Toyota being sent to the back of the grid. The race is reduced to 77 laps. As the cars set off on the second parade lap Panis fails to get off the line and has top be pushed into the pit lane, from where he eventually joins the race.
Lap 1: At the start Jarno Trulli and Fernando Alonso get away well and Alonso gets ahead of Jenson Button as they go into the first corner. Takuma Sato makes the best start and brushing past Michael Schumacher and Kimi Raikkonen emerges in fourth place. Raikkonen is fifth with Michael Schumacher sixth ahead of Rubens Barrichello, David Coulthard, Juan Pablo Montoya and Mark Webber. At the back Christian Klien tangles with Zsolt Baumgartner. Klien tries to keep going but understeers into the wall at the Grand Hotel Hairpin. At the end of the lap Trulli is 0.8s ahead of Alonso.
Lap 3: The first three cars have pulled away from the field which is bottled up behind Sato. The Japanese driver has an engine problem and puffs of smoke appear from the rear of his car. As he goes into Tabac Corner, the engine blows. Sato pulls off to the inside as the others try to find a way through in the smoke. Montoya and Webber get through but Coulthard slows and is hit from behind by Giancarlo Fisichella. The Sauber flies over the rear of the McLaren and ends up upside-down. The Safety Car is sent out immediately. Fisichella emerges unscathed. Coulthard goes to the pits but the damage to the rear of the car is too much and he too is out. Ralf Schumacher, who is running in 13th place also pits.
Lap 4: As the cars circulate behind the Safety Car, Jordan decides to bring in Nick Heidfeld in the hope of getting a strategic advantage. The German rejoins without loosing a place.
Lap 8: The race restarts at the beginning of lap eight and Montoya scrambles past Barrichello at Ste Devote to move up to sixth place.
Lap 10: At the front Trulli sets the fastest lap of the race while at the back of the field Ralf Schumacher is finally able to overtake Baumgartner for 15th place.
Lap 12: Trulli sets a third consecutive fastest lap but his lead over Alonso is still only 1.2s. Eighth-placed Webber pulls off with a mechanical problem and at the back Ralf Schumacher gets ahead of Gianmaria Bruni to move up to 13th place.
Lap 13: Montoya stops and falls back from sixth place to 10th. Giorgio Pantano, who is running 11th disappears with mechanical trouble.
Lap 16: Trulli has pushed his lead out to 2.7secs while Alonso remains under pressure from Jenson Button. There is then a gap back to Raikkonen and Schumacher. Barrichello is sixth with Cristiano da Matta in seventh with Felipe Massa chasing him in the Sauber. In ninth place is Nick Heidfeld's Jordan but he is under pressure from Montoya. The only other runners are Olivier Panis, Ralf Schumacher and the two Minardis. Bruni pits and drops behind Baumgartner.
Lap 18: Button heads for the pits and falls back from third place to seventh.
Lap 19: Raikkonen now pits and he rejoins still behind Button. The disappearance of the McLaren means that Michael Schumacher can speed up.
Lap 20: Fourth-placed Barrichello goes into the pits for his first stop. Michael Schumacher sets the first of four consecutive fastest laps as he tries to make up lost ground.
Lap 21: Seventh-placed Massa comes into the pits and falls back to 10th.
Lap 23: Trulli increases his lead to 4.1secs while Alonso is still 4.4s ahead of Schumacher, despite the fact that Schumacher has done four fastest laps, bringing down the gap from 6.6s. Fourth-placed Da Matta pits and drops back to seventh.
Lap 24: Trulli stops and Alonso goes into the lead with Schumacher second. Trulli rejoins third. Further back Panis pits for the first time.
Lap 25: Alonso stops and so Michael Schumacher takes the lead. Alonso rejoins third ahead of Button.
Lap 26: Schumacher pits but when he comes out he is still behind Trulli and Alonso. His fast laps mean that he is now ahead of both Raikkonen and Button. Barrichello is sixth with Da Matta seventh and Heidfeld in eighth.
Lap 28: Raikkonen goes into the pits and retires with mechanical trouble.
Lap 29: Montoya and Heidfeld have been fighting for seventh place, the two men going across the chicane on lap 28. In the Mirabeau corner Heidfeld makes a mistake and Montoya is able to get ahead at the Grand Hotel Hairpin.
Lap 31: Heidfeld pits and falls back from eighth to 10th.
Lap 32: Traffic has closed the gap between Trulli and Alonso but it is clear that Jarno is faster as he begins to build his lead again. Michael Schumacher is third with Button fourth, Barrichello fifth and da Matta sixth.
Lap 37: Trulli has increased his lead again to 2.4s but the order is unchanged. Ninth-placed Ralf Schumacher pits and drops behind Heidfeld.
Lap 42: Alonso tries to lap Ralf Schumacher in the tunnel but gets offline and crashes heavily. A Safety Car is sent out and Button, da Matta, Montoya, Massa and Heidfeld all go into the pits.
Lap 43: Trulli stops and Michael Schumacher goes into the lead but behind the Safety Car. Immediately behind him on the road is Montoya.
Lap 46: The field is getting ready to restart when Michael Schumacher slows in the tunnel. Montoya tries to avoid the Ferrari but the two cars seem to collide and Schumacher goes into the barriers. He drives to the pits and retires.
Lap 47: Trulli begins to pull away again with Button behind him and Barrichello third but unable to keep up the same pace. Everyone else is a lap behind with Montoya fourth, da Matta fifth and Massa sixth and Heidfeld seventh. A further lap behind is Ralf Schumacher and Panis. The only other runner is Baumgartner.
Lap 52: Da Matta is given a drive-through penalty for failing to observe blue flags and this drops him behind Massa.
Lap 55: Barrichello pits but he remains in a solid third place but is now nearly 40 seconds behind Button. Further back Panis also stops again but he stays ninth.
Lap 70: The order is unchanged but Ralf Schumacher goes out with a mechanical problem, retiring from eighth place.
Lap 74: Button has closed to within a second of Trulli but there is little chance he can overtake. Further back Massa is under great pressure from da Matta.
Lap 77: Trulli wins his first victory with Button just 0.497s behind him. Barrichello is third. Montoya is a lap down but finishes fourth while Massa and da Matta cross the line side-by-side, the Sauber a tenth of a second ahead of the Toyota. Heidfeld is seventh with Panis and Baumgartner the only other finishers.
© 2007 autosport.com
. This service is provided under the Atlas F1 terms and conditions.
Please Contact Us for permission to republish this or any other material from Atlas F1. |