2004 Malaysian Grand Prix Review
By Pablo Elizalde, Spain
Atlas F1 News Editor
World Champion Michael Schumacher dominated the Malaysian Grand Prix from start to finish, just like he had done two weeks earlier in Australia. This time, however, Juan Pablo Montoya made sure the German had to sweat for his victory while Jenson Button also pushed hard to score his maiden F1 podium. Atlas F1's Pablo Elizalde reviews the events and results of the Sepang race
The 2004 Grand Prix season is no different in that respect, although the people's take of the current state of things is, like almost everything in life, open to different interpretations.
Following last weekend's Malaysian Grand Prix, the half-empty-glass view suggests that it looks unlikely that Ferrari and Michael Schumacher will be stopped in the German's chase of a mind-blowing seventh World Championship crown this year. The signs are there for everybody to see.
The Australian Grand Prix, almost everyone agreed, was not the true picture of Ferrari's current form: the coolish weather had played into the Italian team's hands all weekend, and as a result the Bridgestone tyres were the ones to have. As a consequence, Schumacher and Rubens Barrichello dominated the race from start to finish and came close to lapping the entire field.
Malaysia would show a truer picture, everybody said, Ferrari and their rivals included.
So came the sweltering heat of the Asian country, and Schumacher again dominated the Grand Prix from lights to flag without putting a foot wrong, and having started from pole position. It was a race that Schumacher had not won since 2001, and the one were the Michelin runners were supposed to have the upper hand.
In reality, all of Schumacher's main rivals were a lot closer than they were in Australia, but there was not a single moment in which the German's lead was actually challenged. Finishing some five seconds behind is a step forward for Williams after they were almost lapped in Melbourne.
Sepang was, in theory, Williams' track, and it is true the British squad were much closer than in Australia. But a lesson the past year has taught is that, when the races are close, Schumacher emerges as the winner most of the time. A team will need to be superior to Ferrari to beat Schumacher, and two races into the season it's the World Champions who have the leading package.
After the race, Michelin boss Pierre Dupasquier raised a very interesting point against Ferrari's rivals when asked if Schumacher could be stopped this season. "I don't see how," answered the Frenchman. "We also have another handicap in that since our partners are close to each other, they will share the points. And all the red points will go to Michael."
If Bridgestone are superior at any given track, then Ferrari are likely to win. If Michelin are superior, then Williams, Renault, McLaren, and now BAR will be fighting against each other, to Ferrari's benefit. If anyone still wonders why Ferrari are sticking with Bridgestone, that's one of the best answers you could get.
However, the half-full-glass view offers a brighter prospect for the season ahead, as the Sepang race offered hope for Ferrari's rivals after the Australian Grand Prix debacle.
Williams, or rather Juan Pablo Montoya, followed Schumacher closely for the whole race, and there were moments in which the Colombian looked set to catch the German, especially when he set the fastest lap of the race, which was more than half a second quicker than what the Ferrari driver managed. Had Montoya not been slowed down by Barrichello following his third pitstop, the Williams driver could have caught Schumacher.
"In a non-Ferrari, it's better to back off than to go out of the race. It's better to go home with eight points," said a grim-faced Montoya after the race. "As soon as I went to move he moved and there was no point even trying to pass. There were 12 laps to go, I had new tyres so I just backed off and cruised."
If Montoya pressured Schumacher all the way, the Colombian himself was also chased closely by the BAR of Jenson Button, who completed another impressive race following the promise of Australia. The Briton was fast and consistent all weekend long and was rewarded with his first ever podium, which was also BAR's first top three finish on merit following a couple of lucky podiums. If the Honda-powered team can keep up with the development rate of their rivals, their first victory could be not far away.
In Malaysia, BAR seemed to take Renault's position following the troubled weekend the French squad had, which in the end did not reflect their true pace. Jarno Trulli and especially Fernando Alonso made a mess of their qualifying laps and paid the price for it. The Spaniard's chances to fight at the top were null starting from the back of the grid, and the wrong strategy did not help him either. In the end, Renault showed good pace and reliability, but the result wasn't even close to what they had hoped for.
For McLaren, the Malaysian Grand Prix left a bitter-sweet taste; although it was probably more bitter than sweet. After their dismal performance in Australia, the silver cars, and especially Kimi Raikkonen, fared better during most of the weekend. Raikkonen would have been unable to finish on the podium, but the gap to their rivals did not look as alarming as in Melbourne.
Nonetheless, Raikkonen's second retirement in a row was a reminder that McLaren have still a long way to go before returning to winning ways. This time last year, the Finn was in the lead of the Championship with 16 points. After the Sepang race - which marked a year since McLaren's last win - Raikkonen is yet to see the chequered flag and trails the Championship leader by 20 points. The European season, and with it new developments, cannot come quick enough for the Finn.
Qualifying
After two weeks full of talk and speculation, the very unpopular two-run qualifying stayed for the Malaysian Grand Prix if only for the sake of seeing, as McLaren boss Ron Dennis put it, what the reaction was. And even himself admitted that change is knocking on F1's door.
"Perhaps there is some argument that says let's wait two or three races until we know exactly what the reaction is but there appeared to be quite significant reaction coming after Australia so maybe it is a case of better sooner rather than later," Dennis said.
The FIA already announced a change in schedule for the Bahrain Grand Prix "in order to facilitate television scheduling". In other words, it seems the networks want to know the exact time the second qualifying session will start so they can skip the first one and show the important stuff.
Unlike in Australia, the second qualifying session for the Malaysian Grand Prix showed some excitement, even if not for pole position, but the first hour again highlighted the drawbacks of this new system, which made qualifying last for a massive 124 minutes, which was almost what the Grand Prix and the post-race press conference put together lasted.
The Grid
1. Michael Schumacher
2. Mark Webber
3. Rubens Barrichello
4. Juan Pablo Montoya
5. Kimi Raikkonen
6. Jenson Button
7. Ralf Schumacher
8. Jarno Trulli
9. David Coulthard
10. Cristiano da Matta
11. Felipe Massa
12. Giancarlo Fisichella
13. Christian Klien
14. Oliver Panis
15. Nick Heidfeld
16. Gianmaria Bruni
17. Zsolt Baumgartner
18. Giorgio Pantano
19. Fernando Alonso
20. Takuma Sato
The Race
After Saturday's qualifying, Giorgio Pantano became the first victim of the new regulations, when he was penalised for using the spare Jordan with a new engine fitted to it. Others, meanwhile took advantage of their poor positions to replace their power plants ahead of the race. That was how Alonso and Sato began the race with unused engines, which were taken from the spare cars and fitted in their racing machines.
Of course the penalty made no difference to their qualifying positions.
Before the grid was formed, the threatening grey skies opened briefly, which was enough to make the track extremely slippery. So much, in fact, that Raikkonen spun during the formation lap, although fortunately for the Finn, he was able to turn his car around and return to his position before being passed by the last car.
The fear of Webber blocking the field while Schumacher flew away from his rivals disappeared as soon as the red lights went off, the Australian getting stuck at the start due to a problem with the software of his Jaguar. From second Webber dropped down to 15th position, all his chances of fighting at the top gone.
Schumacher did not have much trouble keeping the lead, and he was followed by Barrichello, which was bad news for Ferrari's rivals. Montoya followed, with Raikkonen in fourth, Trulli in fifth, Button sixth, and Coulthard and Ralf completing the top eight. At the back of the grid, Alonso had made the most amazing of starts, overtaking several cars before the end of the straight and completing the first lap in ninth position, which made for an incredible recovery.
With the track still damp following the short shower, the drivers struggled with their cars, and on the second lap Barrichello ran wide and allowed Montoya and Raikkonen to move ahead. The initial track conditions seemed to benefit the Michelin runners, and Montoya got closer to Schumacher before the track dried up completely and the Ferrari driver pulled away from his rival. A little further back, Trulli and Button were entertaining the crowd with their battle, which ended when the BAR driver overtook the Italian for fifth position.
By the fifth lap, Schumacher was over three seconds in front of Montoya, who had pulled away from Raikkonen and Barrichello, the Brazilian unable to get close to the Finn. Button was still fifth in front of Trulli and Coulthard, who had Alonso now breathing down his neck. Ralf was outside the points and trying to keep Webber at bay when the Australian tried to go around the outside at the first corner. His Jaguar's rear right wheel made contact with the Williams's front wing, which resulted in a puncture for Webber, who nursed his car back to the pits, only to be penalised for speeding in the pitlane and later spinning out of the race.
"Ralf drove into the back of me because he was pissed off that I'd overtaken him," said Webber. "I got a puncture from that and had to stop and then I spun out. It is absolutely frustrating. I had a lot of rear tyre wear but that was my fault because I've got to drive in those conditions. But we'll keep on learning."
At the top of the field Schumacher continued to open his gap to Montoya as the Ferrari driver took advantage of his lighter fuel load. When Schumacher dived into the pits for his first stop, he was around five seconds ahead of the Colombian driver, who was still able to stay on track for a couple of laps, suggesting he was running with more fuel than the German in qualifying.
Montoya was, together with Button, the last of the top runners to pit, the Colombian stopping on lap 12 and returning to the race right behind Raikkonen, whom the Williams driver overtook on that same lap. Button dropped to fifth place behind Trulli, after the Italian had jumped ahead of Barrichello in the pitlane.
Initially, the second stint saw Schumacher continuing to increase his lead over Montoya to over six seconds by lap 15, but the Williams driver began to push harder and, with a series of very fast laps, closed in on his rival, the gap reduced by half three laps later. Raikkonen had lost contact with the leading duo, and was followed closely by a charging Trulli. Button and Barrichello were not far behind, with Coulthard in seventh and Alonso right behind in eighth.
After only ten laps on track, Trulli became the first driver to stop for the second time, on lap 20, dropping from fourth to ninth. His Renault teammate Alonso, meanwhile, was putting Coulthard under pressure and finally managed to overtake the Scot with a gutsy move around the outside of turn one. The McLaren driver, however, recovered his position moments later when both men pitted at the same time, Alonso loading a lot more fuel than the Scot as Renault had decided to change their strategy to a two-stopper.
The rest of the top runners completed their second stop between lap 25 and 28, and while Schumacher and Montoya kept their positions, Raikkonen lost out to Button, who moved into third. Barrichello, who had led briefly while the others pitted, regained fifth place from Trulli while Coulthard was still in sixth ahead of Sato and Alonso. Ralf's anonymous race came to an end on lap 28 when his BMW engine let go as the German driver was running outside the point-scoring positions.
Bit by bit, Montoya continued his charge towards Schumacher, in the meantime setting the quickest lap of the race, to reduce the gap to the German to around five seconds with some 25 laps remaining. After the initial on-track action, the order settled, with only Alonso and Sato exchanging positions as the BAR driver, up until then running in eighth, pitted for the second and final time on lap 35. Alonso, meanwhile, was struggling for pace, his two-stop strategy clearly not paying off.
The final round of pitstops began around lap 38, when Coulthard stopped and rejoined in the same position. Montoya, some four seconds behind Schumacher, pitted next and returned to the race behind Barrichello, who had still a few laps to go before going into the pits. The rest of the top runners pitted, and the order stayed the same until Raikkonen retired with a blown engine on lap 41, much to the dismay of the angry Finn, who lost his cool and pushed a marshal who tried to show him the way out of the track.
At the front, Schumacher extended his lead while Montoya was stuck behind Barrichello until lap 44, when the Brazilian finally pitted. The Colombian driver was not amused after the race.
"At the end we backed off the revs, we backed off everything when Rubens got in the way. I went to pass him and he blocked me," he said. "If I hadn't had Rubens in the last stint, I think we could have been quite a bit closer because at the end I was really cruising."
Montoya was unable to challenge Schumacher again, the Colombian settling for second as his rival cruised home to score his second consecutive victory to complete a perfect start to the season. As usual, the World Champion kept his feet on the ground.
"No doubt, it's only two out of 18 races - 16 to go," said the German. "I have 20 points in my pocket, which is more than last year. But relaxed would certainly be the wrong word. It was pressure all the way."
After 68 starts, Button finally made it onto the podium after a flawless drive, beating his rivals fair and square to give BAR their first ever podium scored on pure merit. Barrichello had to settle for fourth, having been unable to catch Button in the final part of the race.
"We are ecstatic," said the Briton. "It's the first time I've been on the podium in four years. It's been a struggle but it's a fantastic feeling to be here," said Button, after his first top-three finish. "Obviously, this is a great step in the right direction but it's not the pinnacle of what we want."
Trulli was fifth for Renault, who scored double points thanks to Alonso's seventh place, but who were disappointed not have achieved a better result. The French cars were split by Coulthard, who brought his McLaren home in sixth in what was not much consolation for the Mercedes-powered team. Massa scored the final point for Sauber, making it three Ferrari-powered cars in the points.
So was the Malaysian Grand Prix further proof of Ferrari's dominance in all kinds of conditions? Or an indication that their rivals will give them a good run for their money all season long? Until time tells the real story, it all depends on how you see the glass.
The grid lines up with rain clouds threatening the Sepang circuit. Giorgio Pantano is going to start from the pitlane. There is some rain at the back of the track and on the final installation lap Kimi Raikkonen spins his McLaren. Fortunately he is able to retake his grid position because he is able to rejoin before the last car passes him.
Lap 1: At the start Mark Webber gets away very slowly and as the cars head for the first corner, it is a Ferrari 1-2 with Michael Schumacher ahead of Rubens Barrichello. Third is Juan Pablo Montoya in his Williams with Kimi Raikkonen fourth, Jenson Button and Jarno Trulli disputing fifth. Further back Webber has a great lap making up places and crosses the line in eighth place, having made his way up from around 15th place. Also on the move in Fernando Alonso, who has gone from the back of the grid to ninth. The top 10 is completed by Takuma Sato. At the tail of the field Giorgio Pantano spins, probably because he started on cold tyres. By the end of the first lap Michael Schumacher has a two second lead over Barrichello.
Lap 2: With half the race track dry and the other half a little damp, the Michelin cars have an advantage. Barrichello runs wide and this allows Montoya and Raikkonen to move up to second and third places. Montoya closes quickly on Schumacher and gets to within a second of the leader. The Trulli-Button battle continues with Jenson getting ahead. Further back Ralf Schumacher re-passes Webber while Sato has a spin and drops back to 15th place. Giancarlo Fisichella is also in trouble and drops from 16th to 19th.
Lap 3: As the track dries Schumacher begins to pull away again, increasing his lead to 1.6 seconds. Montoya is able to pull away from Raikkonen while Barrichello drops away. Button is next up with Trulli on his tail and Coulthard chasing. Ralf Schumacher is overtaken by Webber and Alonso while Fisichella recovers and is back up to 17th.
Lap 4: As Michael Schumacher sets the fastest lap of the race, increasing his lead to 1.8secs., the battle between Webber and Alonso is very close and Fernando gets ahead. Fisichella moves up from 17th to 15th. Sato is also in trouble and loses three places to end up 18th.
Lap 5: Schumacher increases his lead to 3.2secs.There is drama for Webber, who has a left rear puncture. He is forced to drive slowly around to the pits for a new tyre. This promotes Ralf Schumacher to ninth place and Felipe Massa to 10th.
Lap 6: Schumacher increases his lead again to 4.2secs. The order remains the same although at the back Sato begins his recovery, overtaking Gianmaria Bruni for 16th.
Lap 8: The order has settled down but Giancarlo Fisichella heads for the pitlane for his first pit stop. He drops from 14th to 17th.
Lap 9: Schumacher pits, suggesting that he was running relatively light in qualifying. This puts Montoya into the lead with Raikkonen second, Barrichello third and then the Button-Trulli duo in fourth and fifth. Also pitting are Coulthard, Alonso, Massa, Christian Klien and Bruni.
Lap 10: Montoya stays in the lead and with Raikkonen, Barrichello and Trulli all pitting, this means that Button is second with Ralf Schumacher third and Michael fourth. Trulli rejoins ahead of Barrichello. Further back da Matta stops. Webber pits for a drive-through penalty for speeding in the pitlane.
Lap 11: Ralf Schumacher stops and loses ground, rejoining in 11th place, behind Alonso. The stops continue with Olivier Panis coming in from eighth place. He drops to 12th.
Lap 12: Montoya and Button both pit, leaving Michael Schumacher in the lead again. Montoya rejoins behind Raikkonen but passes him later in the lap to take second again. Trulli also gets ahead of Raikkonen to grab fourth with Button fifth and Barrichello down to sixth. Sato is seventh but has yet to stop while Coulthard is eighth, Alonso ninth. Nick Heidfeld comes into the pits, leaving 10th place to Ralf Schumacher.
Lap 13: Schumacher’s lead is up to 6.4secs. Heidfeld returns to the pits for a second stop.
Lap 14: Montoya sets the fastest lap and closes the gap to 4.6secs, Schumacher losing a little time passing Webber. Sato comes into the pits and falls from seventh place to 11th.
Lap 15: At the back of the field Webber catches and passes Zsolt Baumgartner.
Lap 18: Montoya has managed to close the gap to Schumacher to just 3.3secs. There is then a seven second gap back to Raikkonen who is under pressure from Trulli. Button follows ahead of Barrichello.
Lap 20: The gap has increased again with Schumacher beginning to pull away. Trulli pits and falls back from fourth to ninth after a very short stint of only 10 laps. Further back da Matta has his second stop.
Lap 21: Panis has his second stop but the Toyotas are not competitive.
Lap 22: At the back of the field Webber catches and passes Bruni for 18th place.
Lap 24: Alonso passes Coulthard on the outside at Turn 1 to grab sixth place but both men pit at the end of the lap. Alonso takes on a lot of fuel and so drops behind Coulthard, Massa and Salo. Webber spins off into retirement.
Lap 25: The second stops continue with Raikkonen pitting, allowing Barrichello to move to fourth place and Ralf Schumacher to fifth. Kimi rejoins in sixth. Also pitting is Massa, who falls from ninth to 12th.
Lap 26: The top three all come into the pits. Barrichello thus leads with Michael rejoining second ahead of Montoya, Ralf Schumacher and Trulli. Raikkonen is sixth. Also pitting is Fisichella down in 11th place.
Lap 28: After leading for two laps Barrichello pits and Schumacher goes into the lead again. Montoya sets the fastest lap. Ralf Schumacher disappears with a blown engine. This promotes Button to fourth and Raikkonen to fifth. Trulli is sixth.
Lap 29: Montoya once again begins closing on Schumacher but the order further back is now set.
Lap 32: Montoya has closed to within five seconds of Schumacher. Further back Heidfeld hits troubles with gears and falls down the order.
Lap 34: Heidfeld retires.
Lap 35: Sato, on a two-stop strategy pits from eighth place. He drops behind Alonso, the Spaniard’s lap times suggest that he is not going to stop again.
Lap 36: Down at the back Klien and da Matta pit for a third time. End of the field, Baumgartner does the same.
Lap 38: Coulthard begins the final stops for the leading cars. He holds on to his seventh place. Further back Panis stops for the third time.
Lap 39: Montoya has been unable to get closer than 3.7secs to Schumacher and as he begins to fade again he heads for pitlane. He rejoins in fifth behind Button, Raikkonen and Barrichello.
Lap 40: Schumacher, Button and Raikkonen all stop. Michael comes out in the lead but Montoya is stuck behind Barrichello. Also stopping is Trulli but he remains in sixth place.
Lap 41: Raikkonen retires with a blown engine. This puts Trulli up to fifth place with Coulthard sixth. Alonso is eighth and Sato ninth.
Lap 44: Barrichello finally pits but by then Montoya is more than nine seconds behind Schumacher and decides to settle for second place. Barrichello rejoins in fourth.
Lap 45: Panis goes into the pits for no obvious reason. The Frenchman drives straight through and rejoins, gesticulating in an unhappy fashion. He is later given a drive-through penalty for speeding in pitlane. This drops him back to 12th.
Lap 53: Sato retires with an engine failure. Losing eighth place. This puts Massa into eighth.
Lap 56: Michael Schumacher wins his 72nd victory. Montoya is second and Jenson Button third, delighted to have scored his first F1 podium finish.
© 2007 autosport.com
. This service is provided under the Atlas F1 terms and conditions.
Please Contact Us for permission to republish this or any other material from Atlas F1. |