The 2004 French GP Review
By Tom Keeble, USA
Atlas F1 Magazine Writer
Michael Schumacher and his Ferrari team pulled a strategic masterstroke to score their ninth victory in ten races at last Sunday's French Grand Prix. Although the end result was still the same, this time the World Champions were made to sweat by Renault's Fernando Alonso. Atlas F1's Tom Keeble reviews the entire weekend's event and results of the tenth round of the 2004 season
However, the driver of the weekend has to be Rubens Barrichello, who recovered from a difficult qualifying session to finish on the podium from tenth place including an on-track overtaking manoeuvre: "From tenth to third - I am very happy and I had a lot of fun today. The car was very fast and the Bridgestone tyres were fantastic, especially at the end of each stint. I had a great race and the other drivers were very fair on the track."
The weekend was a tour de force for the Ferrari, illustrating the fantastic teamwork that has led to their dominant season; in Jean Todt's opinion: "I can only feel pride for the way the team has worked, demonstrating yet again that it has a great will to win. It is a fantastic group of people!" The sentiment was backed up by Ross Brawn, whose continued ability to make the right call on strategy was a decisive factor for Schumacher: "Our drivers had an exceptional race
when you have a quicker car it is worth trying an aggressive strategy."
Whilst Ferrari took the opportunity to demonstrate their continued superiority, the rest of the paddock was surprised by Renault's considerable form at this race. Of course, the team had always targeted their home event for improving, but that takes nothing away from the fact they had a very real chance of winning and at least forced Ferrari into a real race. Fernando Alonso was pleased with his performance: "I had a good race, and fought as hard as possible, but I think Michael was just stronger today."
Despite a strong race, Jarno Trulli was disappointed: "I am gutted for myself and the team to have lost third place at the very end of the race
At the moment, all I feel is disappointment, but I will have to get over it and come back stronger at the next races." The sentiment was echoed by the Flavio Briatore: "Fernando was excellent throughout the race and deserves his second place. It was, though, very disappointing to see Jarno miss out on a podium by just several tenths of a second." Going forward it would be a shame for the team to be carrying that negative aspect from such a positive race.
BAR had a very unsatisfactory race: both their cars should have finished high in the points, but it was not to be. Jenson Button's fifth place was a huge disappointment to the team, as it so easily could have been a podium finish. A simple stutter from the anti-stall mechanism in the last pitstop caused him to exit behind Trulli, and give Barrichello a run to pass in the hairpin: "I'm very disappointed because we expected to do a lot better here and fifth is not good enough. The strategy was working well for us but at the last pit stop the engine went into anti-stall mode and cost me the time advantage that could have put us on the podium."
Meanwhile, Takuma Sato's engine expired yet again. As Dave Richards said, "one can't help but feel disappointed that we didn't make the most of our potential here in Magny-Cours." The cat is really out of the bag with this one now, and the onus is on Honda to establish why it is Sato who has so many problems, and to resolve the issue. Honda's Shuhei Nakamoto was frank: "Taku's engine failed again so we will work very hard this week to find the cause and put a counter measure in place for the next race at Silverstone."
Fortunes at McLaren were transformed this weekend. Their new car shows considerably better form than the old, and it was considerably improved in qualifying. Race day pace was not quite so consistent, but it seems they now have a base that is worth developing. More to the point, as their understanding of the revised chassis improves, so will their pace. Leading the change, Coulthard was pleased: "an encouraging and reliable race debut for the 19B and I'm looking forward to my home Grand Prix at Silverstone next weekend and the rest of the season."
Ron Dennis was happy with the performance: "It might not be apparent from our finishing positions but the MP4-19B is definitely a significant step in the right direction." Norbert Haug was even more enthused, believing the team might have challenged for the podium: "We had the speed for third place today but David lost two positions at the start whilst Kimi gained two."
Renault and McLaren's gain was most certainly Williams loss. Having Marc Gene standing in for Ralf Schumacher was bad enough, but their revised package didn't quite seem to come together this weekend. Moreover, Juan Pablo Montoya hurt himself in a big crash on Friday: "It has been a very difficult race for me, especially because of an intense pain in my neck, which nearly prevented me from being able to keep my head up."
Marc Gene's race was not impressive, largely due to a poor start: "I had a problem with the clutch on the grid but since I didn't want to jump the start I released it very slowly and lost three positions." Sam Michael blamed the poor results from the weekend on the car: "Since our race strategy, tyres and pit stops were fine, we obviously need to keep pushing to improve the pace of the car." Though Mario Theissen spread the blame further: "Juan lost some positions due to his spin and Marc lost three places in the heat of the start
wasn't a chance to do any proper testing of the new parts prior to this race weekend." Mind you, he was happy with the performance of the engine, which continues to be a consistent performer for the team.
Jaguar had a better weekend than usual, with Mark Webber collecting ninth place: "The team has done an amazing job all weekend and to see us finishing both cars in 9th and 11th after only one retirement is really testament to the hard work we have been undertaking here at the track and back in the factory." Christian Klein thinks he is finally getting it all sorted out, too: "This weekend has really been a good step-forward for me as I feel everything is coming together." The car was well balanced and relatively quick though there is still work to be done to catch those ahead.
Sauber expected a tough weekend, and were not disappointed. They had some consolation being quicker than Toyota, but they simply didn't have the pace to challenge the main Michelin runners this weekend. Toyota, meanwhile, simply failed to set the car up to manage the increasing heat, and the cars became very awkward to drive, turning a relatively satisfactory qualifying into a poor race.
Jordan had the scant consolation of knowing they were better than Minardi, but there was no getting away from the fact their pace was simply inadequate. The car had reasonable balance, but grained the tyres too easily: front wear was the main problem, which was a contrast to the rest of the field. Minardi, meanwhile, performed their usual job at the back; Zsolt Baumgartner's spin ended his race prematurely, but didn't make any discernable difference to a race with 18 finishers.
All told, the French Grand Prix was a processional affair, demonstrating that the top four Michelin runners are currently performing similarly, and that Ferrari still have a strategic edge when their absolute speed is questioned.
With the Friday sessions effectively rendered useless by rain, the teams did all their set-up work on Saturday and chose their tyres for the event immediately before the first qualifying session. Times in France tend to be fairly close, so the reduced set-up time should typically have spread the field out; in the event, the smoothness of the circuit means that the teams largely still got their acts together quite quickly, though race day might reveal more wear problems than might otherwise be expected.
The weather for qualifying was sunny, with a track temperature of 38 degrees for the session. This was an increase from qualifying, leading the Bridgestone runners in particular to suffer increased oversteer.
The Grid
1. Fernando Alonso
2. Michael Schumacher
3. David Coulthard
4. Jenson Button
5. Jarno Trulli
6. Juan Pablo Montoya
7. Takuma Sato
8. Marc Gene
9. Kimi Raikkonen
10. Rubens Barrichello
11. Cristiano da Matta
12. Mark Webber
13. Christian Klien
14. Olivier Panis
15. Giancarlo Fisichella
16. Felipe Massa
17. Nick Heidfeld
18. Giorgio Pantano
19. Gianmaria Bruni
20. Zsolt Baumgartner
The Race
The day dawned bright and sunny, with the no wind worthy of the name, air temperature of 28 degrees, and a track temperature that was up from qualifying at 43 degrees.
The start was clean, except for Panis, whose take off looked very slow. Schumacher made his characteristic chop, but remained behind Alonso. Trulli made a blinding start to move into third, and defended successfully an attack from Button into Adelaide. Button's fourth place was at the expense of Coulthard, slow off the line. Gene also had a poor start and dropped to eleventh. The field proceeded to spread out slowly, with no obvious passing opportunities arising, except for Panis making his way forward from the back of the pack.
On the third lap, Coulthard and Barrichello went through the speed trap at over 200mph: these cars are showing the best top speeds of the weekend. Barrichello, charging back from his poor qualifying position, passed Sato to move into eighth.
Meanwhile at the front, Schumacher and Alonso traded fastest times to open their gap to the rest of the field. The World Champion held station 1.5 seconds off the race leader for the first eight laps, before closing on Alonso.
The Ferrari driver pitted for the first time after 11 laps very quick with 7.4 seconds stationary, returning in eighth. He was followed in by Raikkonen, Gene and da Matta. Alonso's continued running surprised a lot of onlookers who expected the Renault to be lighter on fuel following qualifying.
Barrichello and Coulthard stopped on lap 12 - the Scot was very fast coming out. Trulli stopped on lap 13 with Montoya also stopping and nearly stalling. Alonso lapped cleanly at the front whilst Schumacher was stuck behind Sato. The Spaniard finally stopped on lap 14, followed in by Button. Alonso's return to the circuit was just in front of Sato, retaining the race lead. The BAR driver pitted on lap 15, but shortly after his stop, Sato's engine gave up again, accounting for his sixth retirement in ten races.
After the stops had shaken out, Schumacher was around three seconds off Alonso's lead, with Trulli a further four back. Button, Coulthard and Montoya followed at a reasonable distance, with Barrichello closing on the Williams. Further back, the two-stopping Massa was holding up Raikkonen, who was being pressured by Webber, also on a two-stopper.
At the end of lap 18, Montoya, struggling with neck problems, span on the final kerbs, dropping to ninth behind Raikkonen. The Williams driver not at all happy with the handling of the car, and remained behind Massa until the Sauber pitted on lap 21. Montoya immediately opened up air to Webber behind as he set about closing down Raikkonen, though he was struggling to keep the car on the road. At the front, Schumacher was closing in on Alonso.
Raikkonen made his second stop on lap 27 with Coulthard and Schumacher stopping on lap 28: it was a quick stop, but the German returned in fifth, behind Barrichello. Coulthard's stop included fuel hose trouble which dropped him to eighth.
Button pitted from third on lap 30, and he was followed by Trulli and Barrichello, who pitted from second and third as Schumacher set a new fastest lap. Montoya came in from sixth,while Alonso finally stopped on lap 32, staying stationary for 6.2 seconds, and returning to the circuit behind Schumacher, who had set another fastest lap.
The Renault driver set about closing the three-second difference with some quick laps of his own. However, Schumacher managed to stretch his lead as the fuel levels dropped. Meanwhile, Button was pushing Trulli, looking for the final podium place, whilst Barrichello continued with his progression and was closing on the pair.
Schumacher pitted on lap 42, returning in clean air in second place, eleven seconds behind the leader. This was earlier than expected for a three-stop approach, illustrating how he had used short fuel to gain the lead in the first place.
Alonso faced traffic, but really needed to keep the hammer down: Schumacher was clearly intent on closing the gap down. At this point, considering his blistering pace, it seemed that he could have switched to a four-stop strategy, as unlikely as that sounded.
Alonso made his final stop on lap 45, and he was followed by Raikkonen, running in seventh place, on lap 47. Coulthard and Trulli stopped on the next couple of laps, with Montoya pitting from sixth on lap 50. Barrichello pitted for that last time on lap 51.
At the front, Schumacher was lapping in the 1.15s against Alonso's 1.16s, the Ferrari driver pushing hard to make the space to pit again and return in the lead. By lap 52, Schumacher's lead was up to 15.5 seconds.
Button pitted from third on that same lap, with a nearly stall causing him to come out just behind Trulli, and allowing Barrichello a run on him to pass at the hairpin. The mistake - attributed to Honda's anti-stall - was costly for Button, who saw any chances of a podium finish evaporating.
The Briton could do nothing more than set about pressuring Barrichello, who at the same time was putting Trulli under pressure, to no avail.
By lap 57, Schumacher had opened the gap to Alonso to 20.3 seconds, and was still lapping more than a second a lap quicker than the Renault driver. The pit crew came out, and with 12 laps to go, the World Champion pitted for the fourth time. Less than six seconds later, he was moving again to return seven seconds in front of his rival.
Despite Barrichello pushing Trulli hard, it looked like there would be no further action on the track as the procession lapped its way to the end, with Schumacher winning by ten seconds over Alonso. Then, however, two corners from the end, Barrichello forced his way past Trulli to steal third place with an audacious overtaking manoeuvre a fantastic way to end the drive from tenth on the grid.
Lap 1: At the start of the race Fernando Alonso goes into the lead with Michael Schumacher following while Jarno Trulli bursts through to third place ahead of Jenson Button and a slower-starting David Coulthard. Juan Pablo Montoya was next with a fast-starting Kimi Raikkonen up to seventh from ninth of the grid ahead of Takuma Sato, Rubens Barrichello and Mark Webber, who forced his way ahead of Marc Gene is the course of the lap. The big loser on the first lap is Olivier Panis who gets off the line slowly and ends up at the back of the field. At the end of the lap Alonso is 0.8secs ahead of Schumacher with Trulli a second behind the Ferrari.
Lap 2: Alonso sets the fastest lap of the race to pull out a lead of 1.2secs. At the tail of the field Panis passes Zsolt Baumgartner for 19th.
Lap 3: The two leaders trade fastest laps but the order behind them is the same except towards the back where Giancarlo Fisichella passes Giorgio Pantano for 15th. Further back Panis passes Gianmaria Bruni for 18th.
Lap 4: Alonso sets another fastest lap and extends his lead to 1.4secs. Michael Schumacher is a second and a half ahead of Trulli. In the midfield Barrichello passes Sato for eighth place.
Lap 7: Alonso sets his sixth consecutive fastest lap but this is beaten by Schumacher so that the gap remains at 1.5secs but the two men have left Trulli in their wake, the second Renault now four seconds behind.
Lap 10: Schumacher has closed the lead to just 0.6secs.
Lap 11: The pit stops begin with Schumacher coming in unexpectedly, leaving a Renault 1-2 with Button third. Michael rejoins in eighth place. Further back Kimi Raikkonen stops and drops from seventh to 13th. Also pitting are Gene, Cristiano da Matta and Baumgartner.
Lap 12: The stops continue with fourth-placed Coulthard dropping back to ninth and sixth-placed Barrichello dropping to 10th.
Lap 13: Alonso remains ahead but second-placed Trulli goes into the pits and lets Button move to second with Sato third after Montoya pits. Trulli rejoins sixth and Montoya falls back to ninth. In the midfield Raikkonen overtakes Fisichella to take 12th. Gene passes Nick Heidfeld for 15th. Also stopping are Pantano, Panis and Bruni.
Lap 14: Alonso and Button both pit and Alonso comes out in the lead with Sato second and Schumacher third, Webber is up to fourth ahead of Trulli. Button rejoins in sixth.
Lap 15: Sato pits and so Alonso is left with a lead of 2.8secs over Schumacher. Webber also pits and so Trulli is back to third with Button fourth, Coulthard fifth and Christian Klien (who is still to stop) in sixth. Montoya is next ahead of Barrichello. Down at the back da Matta passes Heidfeld for 15th place.
Lap 16: Alonso pulls away from Schumacher while Klien heads for the pits and falls down the order from sixth to 13th. The race has its first retirement as Sato suffers an engine failure.
Lap 17: Alonso continues to build up his lead with Trulli dropping away all the time. Webber passes Fisichella for 10th place. Montoya spins at the final corner and falls from sixth place to ninth, behind Barrichello, Felipe Massa (who is still to stop) and Raikkonen.
Lap 18: Heidfeld has his first pit stop and falls from 15th to 17th.
Lap 20: The gap at the front has started to close up again. Further back Raikkonen passes Massa to grab seventh. Fisichella pits and falls from 11th to 14th. Further back Pantano drops behind both Panis and Heidfeld.
Lap 21: Massa is the last driver to stop for the first time. The Sauber driver falls back from eighth to 14th.
Lap 25: Schumacher has closed the gap to less than a second but the order is unchanged. Trulli has dropped back and is eight seconds behind Schumacher. Montoya has a small off but does not lose a position.
Lap 28: The second pit stops begin with Raikkonen. He drops from seventh to 10th.
Lap 29: Schumacher comes into the pits. It is a quick stop and Michael rejoins in fifth place. Coulthard also stops and he drops from fifth to eighth. The Renaults are 1-2 again with Button third.
Lap 30: Button pits and goes from third to fifth. Also stopping is da Matta who falls from 12th to 14th.
Lap 31: Alonso continues at the front as Trulli and Barrichello head for the pit lane. Michael Schumacher grabs his opportunity and sets the fastest lap of the race. Montoya stops and falls back from sixth to 11th. Down at the back Pantano calls into the pits.
Lap 32: As Schumacher sets another fastest lap Alonso goes into the pit. The Renault comes out behind the Ferrari. Further back there are stops from Panis and Bruni, while Baumgartner retires out on the circuit.
Lap 33: The gap between Schumacher and Alonso is three seconds. There is then a 12 seconds gap back to Trulli who has Button on his tail. Barrichello is next while Webber goes into pit lane and drops from sixth to 10th. Gene also stops and falls back from eighth to 11th.
Lap 35: Alonso closes the gap to 2.1secs but Trulli begins to drop away quickly. In the midfield Klien pits for the second time, dropping back from eighth to 11th. Further back Heidfeld has his second stop but the team is not ready and he has to do another lap.
Lap 36: The gap starts to increase again. Heidfeld stops again and falls to 17th position.
Lap 37: The order at the front is set although Trulli is coming under more and more pressure from Button. Fisichella has his second stop and drops from 12th to 14th.
Lap 40: Michael Schumacher has increased his lead to nearly five seconds. The order is unchanged except towards the back of the field where Fisichella passes da Matta for 13th place.
Lap 42: There is a surprise as Schumacher heads into pit lane again, suggesting that the Ferrari driver is on a four-stop strategy. Alonso goes into the lead again but Michael rejoins ahead of Trulli.
Lap 43: At the tail of the field Heidfeld passes Pantano for 16th place.
Lap 45: Massa stops for the second time. The Brazilian is doing a two stop race. He drops from 12th to 14th.
Lap 46: Alonso goes into the pits for his third stop. He rejoins more than 11 seconds behind Schumacher.
Lap 47: Raikkonen stops for a third time and he drops from seventh to ninth. Further back da Matta stops again and drops to 14th, behind Massa.
Lap 48: Coulthard is running sixth when he stops for the third time. He falls back behind Montoya and Webber. At the back Pantano stops again. He speeds in the pit land and is given a drive-through penalty.
Lap 49: Trulli heads for pit lane, which frees Button in third place. He has Barrichello behind him. Jarno rejoins sixth.
Lap 50: Fifth-placed Montoya stops and drops back to 10th.
Lap 51: The pit stops continue with Barrichello and Webber pitting. Rubens comes out behind Trulli while Webber drops from sixth to 10th.
Lap 52: Button does his third stop but when he comes out of the pits he is behind Trulli and Barrichello in fifth place.
Lap 54: Eighth-placed Gene stops and falls behind Montoya and Webber.
Lap 57: Schumacher has pushed hard and has built himself a lead of 22 seconds over Alonso. The order is now set behind the leaders although the battle for third is close between Trulli, Barrichello and Button. Further back the two McLarens are running together in sixth and seventh places. Montoya is eighth.
Lap 58: Schumacher pits and re-emerges still in the lead.
Lap 70: Schumacher wins his ninth victory in 10 races. Alonso is second but on the last lap Trulli leads a gap at the penultimate corner and Barrichello grabs third from Jarno. Button is fifth.
© 2007 autosport.com
. This service is provided under the Atlas F1 terms and conditions.
Please Contact Us for permission to republish this or any other material from Atlas F1. |