The Bookworm Critique
By Mark Glendenning, Australia
Atlas F1 Columnist INSIDE THE MIND OF THE
This time around, there's no doubting that he's opted for one of the more intriguing elements of Grand Prix racing – the drivers. Or more particularly, the psychological factors that, million-dollar bank accounts aside, set Michael and Juan Pablo apart from you and I.
It's rare that somebody tackles anything other than the standard driver/team biographies, season reviews, and collections of reminiscences that typify much of the collected published output concerned with racing, so on that basis alone Hilton deserves to be commended. But attempting to communicate the psychological factors that distinguish F1 drivers from the rabble is no mean feat. Phil Shirley had a go at it with his book 'Deadly Obsessions' with hit-and-miss results, and this time around it is pretty much the same story.
What this book does extremely well, however, is impart a sense of how it feels to finally get your foot in the door of Formula One – and then get no further. Perry McCarthy, a talented steerer who became entangled in the embarrassment that was Andrea Moda in the early 1990s, never managed to make the grid. As he tells Hilton, however:
McCarthy's feelings are not universally shared, though, and the book is full of the thoughts of drivers who, for whatever reason, did not come within shouting distance of accomplishing what they wanted to in F1.
The book also contains a few passages that give the reader a good idea of the level of concentration required by Grand Prix drivers. Next time you're arguing with someone who says that F1 drivers are just monkeys reaping the benefits of spooky technology, show them this little extract, which features Bernie Shrosbee (manager of Benetton's Human Performance Centre), describing a test undertaken by Giancarlo Fisichella.
"I know a lot of people feel it happens by habit from repetitive training but the drivers have to keep that focus for close to an hour and 45 minutes and are not allowed to lose concentration for one tenth of a second. You can switch into robotic mode just following the car in front but, most of the time, the best drivers will be pushing, looking for that edge. It's that continuous focus, that continuous discipline to stay on the pace and keep the sharpness, the alertness of reaction." (p. 259-260)
Johnny Herbert says essentially the same thing, albeit a little more vividly:
'Inside the Mind of the Grand Prix Driver' does have its shortfalls, though, and they seem to start with the way the book was initially conceptualised. Hilton doesn't seem to know whether he was trying to write a serious study of driver psychology or a general overview of the topic for a general audience, and the result is a clumsy blend of the two. By and large, the book is well-suited to a general audience of motorsport fans, but the inclusion of small devices such as footnotes (the vast, vast majority of which are unneccessary and only serve to make the book more fiddly to read) may have been a misguided attempt to give the book a heightened sense of credibility.
It follows that the structure of the book is rather vague, a characteristic further illustrated by the hazy subtitle: 'The psychology of the fastest men on earth: sex, danger, and everything else.' The problem is worsened because the balance of drivers selected as interview subjects are far too heavily weighted toward those who never quite made it. Worse still, many 'never quite made it' a few years ago, so it can also seem a little out of date. I am certainly not wishing to diminish the ability or careers of Mark Blundell, Martin Donnelly, or Karl Wendlinger, but given the choice, there are others from whom I’d like to hear about F1 driver psychology.
Most of the other problems that I had with the book related to particular characteristics of Hilton's work that don't tend to sit well with me, but I have written about that many times before, and there's no reason to go over it all again.
Ultimately, though, this is a book that should prove a worthwhile read for most F1 fans. There is a fair bit of fluff padding the pages out, but interspersed throughout is some really fascinating stuff. It's probably not a book that I would hurry to read again, but for the most part I did enjoy sitting down with it, and that is ultimately what we're after.
There's still a few weeks to go before the sound of Grand Prix engines split the air for the first time in 2002 at Albert Park, and if you're looking for something to help pass the time then 'Inside the Mind of the Grand Prix Driver' might be worth a look.
© 2007 autosport.com
. This service is provided under the Atlas F1 terms and conditions.
Please Contact Us for permission to republish this or any other material from Atlas F1. |
|