![]() The 2001 French GP Review
By Pablo Elizalde, Spain
Atlas F1 News Editor
The French Grand Prix marked Michael Schumacher's 50th Grand Prix win, his 6th this season, and his second successive easy win without a challenger in sight. Pablo Elizalde recaps the events of the weekend at Magny Cours
The more disturbing aspect of Schumacher's supremacy, is the fact that the German and his Ferrari team are dominating without even performing at their peak. By now, the whole F1 fraternity knows that Schumacher is capable of more brilliant drives than the ones which have seen him win three of the last four races, but so far he has not needed to exert himself. Taking three wins and one second place in the last four Grands Prix, where the German has extended his lead in the Championship from four points before Monaco to 31 after France, it's clear that Schumacher has not had rivals to fight against.
Meanwhile, in those four events, David Coulthard has stalled before the formation lap in one race, retired in another, and made a costly mistake in the last one. Likewise, Ralf Schumacher has retired once, was penalised in another, and made a costly mistake in yet another race.
At Magny Cours, Ralf looked set for a dominant win after securing his first career pole in what has become the usual family affair in qualifying, but a mistake during one of his pitstops and a bad set of Michelin tyres saw him lose to his elder brother. Teammate Juan Pablo Montoya again showed his improved form and looked capable of finishing in front of Ralf. But the Colombian too succumbed to problems and was forced to retire with an engine failure - the first for BMW since the opening race in Australia.
David Coulthard and the McLaren team were again left with little to aim for but to continue fighting and not giving up before the mathematical chances of winning the Championship are over. But despite Schumacher not allowing himself to be over-confident and Coulthard again vowing to fight on, it looks as though it will take a miracle for the Scot to be back in the title hunt, let alone become World Champion for the first time.
Perhaps for the first time this season, Coulthard made a costly mistake which saw him being penalised with a 10-second stop-go that spoiled all his chances of winning. The McLaren driver made a good recovery, something he seems to have specialised in this year, to continue with his consistent record of finishes.
Despite that, nine points in ten races sound certainly like a ridiculous amount for a two-time Champion like Hakkinen, who is not far from spending a whole year without scoring a win. It's little wonder that the current paddock rumours indicate that McLaren boss Ron Dennis is waiting to hire a second driver before announcing Coulthard will stay with them one more year.
Qualifying
It was only a matter of time before Ralf Schumacher beat his brother Michael in the duel that we've become so accustomed to this season, and which has seen them battle for pole in the last three Grands Prix. In France, the younger of the Schumachers celebrated his 26th birthday with a dramatic first pole position of his career. It was also Williams's first pole since the 1997 European Grand Prix, and Michelin's first since 1984. And, in the process, Ralf shattered the existing track record - set in 1992 by Nigel Mansell with slick-shod Williams - by nearly one second.
Ralf ended a dominant session only a hundredth of a second ahead of Michael, and the overall impression was that Ralf perhaps could have been quicker had he needed to - he was, after all, fastest only in one sector and as low as fourth fastest in the final sector. The younger German also benefited from the heat at the French track - almost 45° Celsius - and from the softer version of the Michelin tyres.
Ralf was next to hit the track, immediately sending a clear warning of his intentions, setting the fastest ever time around the French circuit - 1:13.622. David Coulthard, Michael Schumacher and Juan Pablo Montoya all came out of their pits with 20 minutes gone. Barrichello also returned to the track for his second run, but the Brazilian overshot the Nurburgring chicane and lost his flying lap.
Coulthard and Montoya were unable to demote Ralf from the top of the timesheets, setting the second and fourth quickest times respectively. Schumacher Sr responded to his brother with a 1:13.574 that allowed him to leap to first place. Mika Hakkinen, who had set the pace on Friday, continued with his uphill struggle and was only capable of posting the fifth quickest time.
Meanwhile, Irvine spun on his second attempt, forcing him to run back to the pits to take the spare Jaguar. It was not until half the session had gone by that the Williamses returned to the track. Montoya, the only Michelin runner who had opted for the harder compound, elevated himself to third spot. But it would be Ralf who would shatter the establishment, with an amazing 1:12.989, more than half a second quicker than his brother.
Michael immediately jumped onto the track to challenge Ralf's time and the Ferrari driver's effort was brilliant but not good enough to move ahead of the Williams, staying only seven hundredths of a second behind. Hakkinen, meanwhile, was able to fight his way to third spot three tenths behind Ralf, perhaps a better effort than the Finn could have expected after the gap seen in the previous race.
With some thirteen minutes remaining in the session, the track seemed to be slower, as proved by both Ralf and Montoya, who could not improve, the German not even completing his third flying lap. It started to look highly unlikely that anyone could steal pole from the Williams driver this time.
Surprisingly, Michael came out for his final attempt with seven minutes to go, hoping to avoid the last minute's traffic chaos and have a good shot at pole. Judging by his first two splits, the Ferrari driver looked set to miss on pole for the third time in ten races, and so it was, but he gave it all on the final split and ended his lap only 0.01s behind Ralf. "It's possible I could have gone a little bit faster on my last run, but it's the final result that counts," said Schumacher afterwards.
Only Coulthard was able to gain significant places with his final run, the Scot moving to third ahead of Hakkinen, only two tenths behind Ralf's time. "I'm reasonably happy with starting the race from the second row as I have won from this position before," said Coulthard. "We can definitely take encouragement because we could have performed even better."
Ralf did not even bother to complete his final lap as his first pole was already guaranteed. And after the incident at the start of the last race in Germany, where Michael swerved across the track to block his younger brother into the first corner, the younger Schumacher made clear he was ready to keep his brother at bay at any cost. "I owe him one, definitely," joked Ralf. "I hope that since I am on pole position now I have a good start and then go away. That would be the perfect scenario... But I have to protect my position as he has. Normal thing, isn't it?"
The Race
With track temperatures of 46° Celsius, things looked very promising for the Michelin-shod Williams of Ralf Schumacher. But the new compound introduced by Bridgestone in France seemed to have made up for the gap the French rubber had when temperatures were high, as most of the drivers using the Japanese tyres admitted during the weekend.
So the start took place without the Finn or Spaniard Pedro de la Rosa, who suffered a throttle problem with his Jaguar during the formation lap and was forced to start from the pitlane. With Michael Schumacher continuing with his tendency to make poor getaways, there was no need for Ralf to use the 'chop' to stay in the lead, while his elder brother had to fight to keep David Coulthard behind. The Ferrari driver admitted after the race that a slight problem with his car's clutch was the reason for his slow start.
Most of the teams have clearly improved their launch control systems by now and no major gains or losses were seen at the start, with only Rubens Barrichello moving up three places - from eighth to fifth - behind Juan Pablo Montoya and in front of Jordan's Jarno Trulli who, as usual, shone during qualifying. Sauber's Kimi Raikkonen also made a good start, jumping up to eighth place after starting from 13th spot.
The order remained unchanged for several laps, both at the top and bottom of the field, with most of the drivers struggling to make up places. By lap 10, Ralf was leading his brother Michael by less than two seconds, with Coulthard a similar gap behind and Montoya, using hard tyres, nearly five seconds off the lead.
Apart from that, the laps went by without any action and after a series of fastest laps, Ralf was able to stretch his lead to 2.1 seconds by lap 20. Coulthard was now almost four seconds behind the first Williams and some five in front of the other.
It was not much later - on lap 23 - when the first round of pitstops began, with Ralf diving in for his scheduled stop. Things at the Williams pit, however, did not go according to plan, the German making a mistake which led to a problem with a rear tyre that forced him to stay stationary more than necessary. His stop - 10.9 - was more than three second slower than Michael's - 7.7 - and when the German rejoined the race after refuelling a lap later, he was clearly in front. Coulthard pitted on lap 25, the Scot rejoining in fourth place behind the Schumachers and race leader Montoya.
The Colombian's prospect of fighting for victory looked good considering he was the only driver on the Michelin hard compound and so he was expected to make only one stop. However, when he came into the pits on lap 29, the crowd's hopes of seeing a new winner vanished, as did Coulthard's. On lap 32, the Scot received a ten second stop-go penalty for speeding in the pitlane, probably the first costly error from the McLaren driver, who took the blame for the incident.
"The penalty ruined my race and it was a shame because we were competitive, But I had to face the consequences of my mistake," said Coulthard, who rejoined the race in a distant fifth place behind Montoya, more than 32 seconds off the lead.
After the race, Williams's technical director Patrick Head confirmed the team had asked Ralf to let his teammate through, but the German claimed he was having a problem with his radio and therefore did not hear the team's request. Either way, Ralf did not move over until he came into the pits for his second and final stop on lap 44, rejoining in fifth position. Michael Schumacher pitted one lap later, when he had a gap of 20 seconds over his nearest rival Montoya.
The Colombian would come into the pits for his second stop on lap 49, returning to the track in fourth spot just ahead of teammate Ralf, who was now able to lap at normal pace. Two laps later it was Coulthard's turn to make his stop, the Scot pushing very hard in order to make up for the lost ground. Despite his efforts, Coulthard rejoined in fifth place but he moved up a place on lap 52 when Montoya retired with an engine problem, finishing what seemed set to become his third podium.
On lap 53, Barrichello dived into the pits once more for his third scheduled stop, a strategy not seen for a long time but one that paid off for the Brazilian, who was able to maintain his third place after a poor qualifying performance. The action in front was null, with Schumacher Sr holding a 16-second lead over Ralf, who was now back to second place.
Michael Schumacher cruised home to join Alain Prost in the 50-race wins club, the German scoring his 14th podium in the last fifteen races, showing a sort of dominance hardly ever seen before. As usual, the German, who moved 31 points ahead of Coulthard in the title race, refused to get carried away. "It is a comfortable lead but there are still seven races to go and 70 points to give away," he said. "Until mathematically it is secured I will keep fighting like I did today. As we saw last year things can change very quickly in just two races."
Ralf was second and pleased after his problems: "I am actually happy to sit here in second today because it was a disaster and really difficult to drive." A happy Barrichello was third after a good race, while Coulthard had to settle for fourth, and though he gave his "it's not over yet" speech, the Scot must be starting to wonder if luck will be on his side this year at all. Trulli was the best of the rest, demonstrating once more than when his car is reliable the Italian is one of the best drivers out there.
Now it's back to normal for the teams, with two weeks to go before the British Grand Prix, where McLaren will be hoping for a change in fortune, if not to fight for a title that seems Michael Schumacher's property, at least to show they haven't forgotten how to win. If only for the sake of entertainment, most F1 fans will be crossing their fingers for them.
At the start of the parade lap Mika Hakkinen fails to get off the line. The car is pushed into the pitlane but it cannot be started and Hakkinen is out. At the end of the parade lap Pedro de la Rosa's Jaguar slows and the Spaniard drives into the pitlane.
Lap 2: Ralf increases his lead to three-tenths of a second while Coulthard is able to stay with the two men. Further back in the field Olivier Panis overtakes Eddie Irvine to take 11th position. Jenson Button grabs 16th from his Benetton team mate Giancarlo Fisichella.
Lap 6: At the front Ralf Schumacher's lead grows to one second. Eighth-placed Jacques Villeneuve pulls off with a technical problem.
Lap 15: The order is unchanged when Raikkonen becomes the first man to come into the pits. He drops back from eighth position to 16th.
Lap 18: Enrique Bernoldi's Arrows stops with a mechanical problem. It had been running 14th.
Lap 19: Thirteenth-placed Button stops and loses places to Fisichella, Raikkonen and Jean Alesi.
Lap 20: Fisichella stops and falls behind Raikkonen and Alesi but remains ahead of Button.
Lap 22: Alesi pits and is overtaken by the two Benettons. Fisichella is thus 14th with Button 15th and Alesi 16th.
Lap 23: Ninth-placed Panis stops and drops to 13th place.
Lap 24: Ralf Schumacher pits, allowing Michael to go into the lead. There is a problem with his right rear tyre and he loses a few vital seconds. Also stopping is sixth-placed Frentzen who falls back to 11th place.
Lap 25: Michael pits and Coulthard takes the lead with Montoya behind him. Michael rejoins in third place, ahead of Ralf. Trulli stops and falls from fifth to seventh. Also stopping is eighth-placed Luciano Burti and 10th-placed Jos Verstappen.
Lap 26: Coulthard pits, leaving Montoya in the lead. David rejoins in fourth behind the two Schumacher brothers. David comes out of the pitlane too fast and will later be penalised. At the tail of the field Tarso Marques pits
Lap 27: Sixth-placed Irvine pits and drops back to ninth position.
Lap 28: Michael Schumacher closes rapidly on Montoya. At the tail of the field de la Rosa stops.
Lap 32: Coulthard pits for his 10-second penalty. This drops him back from third to fifth.
Lap 33: Verstappen overtakes Fernando Alonso for 16th place.
Lap 36: Barrichello pits for a second time and drops from third to fourth. It is clear that he is on a three-stop strategy. At the tail of the field Alonso pits.
Lap 40: The second round of stops begin for the two-stop racers with Raikkonen dropping from 10th to 11th.
Lap 41: While Michael Schumacher continues to lead it is clear that Ralf is holding up Montoya. The Williams team tries to get Ralf to move over but the German is having problems hearing his radio and fails to react. Montoya loses important seconds.
Lap 42: Seventh-placed Heidfeld pits and falls behind Frentzen and Irvine.
Lap 43: Irvine overtakes Frentzen for seventh. At the tail of the field de la Rosa stops after a very short middle stint.
Lap 44: After Patrick Head visits the pit walls to give instructions Ralf Schumacher pits for the second time, earlier than planned and falls from second to fifth. This allows Montoya to speed up again. Further back there is a disaster at Benetton when both Fisichella and Button pit at the same time. Button is the man to suffer most.
Lap 45: Michael Schumacher pits and Montoya goes back into the lead. Michael rejoins second but cannot keep up with Montoya's pace. In the midfield Panis pits from 10th place and drops to 13th. Verstappen also stops for a second time and drops back from 14th to 16th.
Lap 46: Eighth-placed Frentzen stops and falls back to 10th.
Lap 48: Irvine stops and so Trulli goes back to sixth place with Heidfeld seventh and Irvine eighth.
Lap 50: Montoya stops and is passed by Michael Schumacher, Barrichello and Coulthard. But he rejoins ahead of Ralf Schumacher.
Lap 51: Barrichello stops and drops behind the two Williams-BMWs.
Lap 53: Montoya pulls off with a mechanical problem. This promotes Coulthard to fourth place, Trulli to fifth and Heidfeld to sixth.
Lap 54: Barrichello goes into the pits for his third stop. He falls to third behind Ralf Schumacher.
Lap 55: Irvine retires with a mechanical problem. Raikkonen inherits seventh place.
Lap 60: As Barrichello soaks up pressure from Coulthard in their battle for third place, Burti overtakes Fisichella to take 10th place.
Lap 61: Button has a spin but remains in 12th place.
Lap 64: De la Rosa finally catches and overtakes Alonso's Minardi to take 15th place.
Lap 69: Button retires with a mechanical problem.
Lap 72: Michael Schumacher wins his 50th Grand Prix victory with Ralf Schumacher second and Barrichello third for Ferrari, having held off Coulthard.. Trulli is fifth with Heidfeld a lap down in sixth place.
© 2007 autosport.com
. This service is provided under the Atlas F1 terms and conditions.
Please Contact Us for permission to republish this or any other material from Atlas F1. |
![]() |
|