2004 San Marino Grand Prix Review
By Pablo Elizalde, Spain
Atlas F1 News Editor
Ferrari and Michael Schumacher continued with their perfect start to the season at Imola, dominating the San Marino Grand Prix despite the best of efforts from BAR and Jenson Button, who were the other stars of the weekend. Atlas F1's Pablo Elizalde reviews the events and results from the fourth round of the 2004 season
"Michael's only rival is himself," Richards reflected after the race. "He has nobody else out there that can hold a torch to him at the moment. But things change. His day will come and somebody else has to come up and challenge him and Jenson's moving forward at a rapid rate of knots."
It is easy to presume that you'd have a hard time finding anyone who disagrees with the first statement following Schumacher's start to the year: four wins in four races to equal his best start to a Formula One season, matching that of 1994, the year when he clinched the first of his six world crowns.
But statistics can be deceiving and they don't tell the whole story of Schumacher's perfect start: it's not only about having scored four victories in as many Grands Prix as it is about how the German has demolished the opposition in all four of them. Suffice to say that the Ferrari driver is yet to have to overtake someone on track; the closest was last Sunday when he moved ahead of Jenson Button during the pistops.
On a weekend where the main issue was the call for change from the powers that be, Formula One responded with a processional race that saw the same winner as in the previous three Grands Prix. While FIA president Max Mosley has proposed radical changes aimed at reducing costs, McLaren boss Ron Dennis highlighted another, if not the biggest concern from the F1 paddock when he said that "the real priority is the need for a better show. We are too easily distracted from that objective."
It's not that hard to sympathize with Dennis as the sport faces the prospect of a repeat of 2002, a season that, like a recurring nightmare, springs to the minds of the Formula One bosses every time Ferrari dominate like on Sunday and the race offers a poor show for the fans.
Unlike in the first three races, Schumacher was unable to start from pole position, although at the end of the day that did not make any difference. The German proved again he has no rivals when it comes to race trim, driving flawlessly into the distance as his F2004 continued to perform as strongly as the driver. The good news for the show was that at least there was a different driver leading the race on merit, even if that only lasted until the first round of pitstops.
You know you belong to the league of the top teams and drivers when you make Michael Schumacher push to the limit and into an error, or when you get an apology from Bernie Ecclestone for believing you didn't have what it takes to succeed in F1. Jenson Button confirmed over the weekend what a mature driver he has become, presenting the only challenge Schumacher faced over the weekend.
Button's lead in the race - following an extraordinary maiden pole position for him and his team - may have been short-lived, but served as further confirmation of the amazing progress of BAR over the winter and since the start of the year. If the Brackley-based squad can keep their momentum going, few would bet against Button scoring his first Grand Prix victory this year.
Ferrari's dominance and BAR's progress is making the rest of the field look like it's going backwards, or at best like they are standing still. At Imola, that seemed to be the case for Williams, who have dropped behind BAR in terms of pace. It was certainly a novelty to hear a Williams driver, Juan Pablo Montoya, complaining about the lack of power from the BMW engine at the end of the race.
That was far from the only thing Montoya was vocal about after the race, the Colombian accusing Schumacher of being "blind or stupid" following a first lap incident between the two. The World Champion knew better than to reply to the furious Williams driver, who had to make do with a distant third place while Schumacher celebrated his 74th victory.
For Renault, the San Marino Grand Prix was always going to be somewhat of a case of damage limitation, the French squad never shining at the Imola circuit. With that in mind, the end result was very satisfactory for them, with Fernando Alonso completing a great race to come home in fourth place. The Spaniard's and Jarno Trulli's strong performances continued to pay dividends and Renault left Italy still in second place in the Constructors' Championship.
As strange as it sounds to hear it, McLaren are now outside the "big four", their place having been inherited by BAR as the Mercedes-powered team continue to struggle for pace and reliability. Although Kimi Raikkonen could finally complete his first Grand Prix distance of the season, the Finn was, for the second consecutive day, forced to start from the back of the field due to a problem with his engine in qualifying.
Fortunately for him, his car lasted the distance and Raikkonen fought his way back into the points thanks to a very distant eighth place. In the post-race statement, the young Finn said he was pleased to have scored one point, his first of the year. But what a difference a year makes: only a year ago he was leading the Championship with 32.
Even if at the end of the weekend it didn't make any difference to the end result of the race, Jenson Button's maiden Formula One pole position underlined the Briton's status as a main challenger to the top positions of this year's Championship.
It also served the purpose of seeing someone other than Michael Schumacher in the top slot for the first time in four races, as well as setting the scene for what was anticipated as a thrilling battle for victory on Sunday. In the end, that was not to be, but Button stated his case and made the six-time World Champion push to the limit and into an uncommon error. And that, these days, is no mean feat.
The Grid
1. Jenson Button
2. Michael Schumacher
3. Juan Pablo Montoya
4. Rubens Barrichello
5. Ralf Schumacher
6. Fernando Alonso
7. Takuma Sato
8. Mark Webber
9. Jarno Trulli
10. Cristiano da Matta
11. David Coulthard
12. Felipe Massa
13. Olivier Panis
14. Christian Klien
15. Giorgio Pantano
16. Nick Heidfeld
17. Gianmaria Bruni
18. Zsolt Baumgartner
19. Giancarlo Fisichella
20. Kimi Raikkonen
The Race
Apart from Schumacher winning all the races so far, there seems to be another constant in this year's Grands Prix: the weather is always cooler on Sunday than on the previous two days. At Imola that happened again: on Saturday afternoon a torrential downpour flooded the circuit, lowering the temperatures and washing the track's surface.
Sunday morning was a different story, however, and the sun shone through, drying up the track before the start of the race. When the race got under way, Button had no problems to keep his lead, making a clean and fast start which allowed him to arrive clearly in front at the first chicane. Schumacher started pretty well too, while Montoya was slower and would have been passed by Ralf had the German found a gap. As it was, he stayed behind.
Arriving at Tamburello, there was plenty of action, most notably by David Coulthard, who was too optimistic under braking and crashed into the back of Alonso's Renault. The Spaniard's car was not damaged, but Coulthard lost his front wing and went off the track before heading into the pits. Alonso, meanwhile, banged wheels with Trulli while going through the first chicane, although both Renaults continued as if nothing had happened.
In the run towards Tosa, Montoya was all over the back of Schumacher. The German defended the inside line and Montoya tried to go around the outside, a move which, as anyone would have expected, did not pay off, as Schumacher widened his line at the exit of the corner and Montoya ended up having to drive onto the grass, losing his momentum. Schumacher played down the incident saying he had not seen Montoya.
"Oh no, he didn't see me there," said the Williams driver after the race. "No chance. You've got to be either blind or stupid not to see me. But you know it is racing." Montoya's complaints fell on deaf ears, especially as he squeezed Ralf only seconds after the incident with Michael, in a move that was remarkably similar. Ironically, he saw nothing wrong with it.
"I did close the door, you know," he said. "I don't have anything against what I did, but it was because of the first incident. I wasn't going to lose 10 positions. I don't have a problem with that, it is fine by me."
Button led at the end of the first lap, with Schumacher nearly three seconds behind. Montoya was third, followed by Sato, Ralf, Barrichello, Trulli and Webber. Alonso had dropped down to ninth after the troubled first lap, with da Matta completing the top ten.
After his flying opening lap, Button began to lose ground to Schumacher, who was the fastest man on track and was getting away from Montoya, unable to follow the pace of the German. It took Schumacher just four laps to get right behind Button; overtaking him, however, was a different matter, so the World Champion waited patiently for the first round of pitstops, which, as usual this year, began pretty soon.
Montoya was the first of the top runners to stop for fuel and tyres, on lap eight, while Button followed suit on the following lap. Schumacher, meanwhile, stayed out for two laps before he made his first pitstop. That was enough for the German to pit and return to the track in the lead, over five seconds ahead of Button. And that was that.
Running in clean air, Schumacher took off, lapping over a second per lap quicker than Button and immediately disappearing into the distance. Behind the BAR driver, Montoya was still a distant and solitary third, while Trulli, the last man to pit, had jumped to fourth in front of Ralf, Barrichello, Alonso and Sato, who was followed closely by Fisichella and Raikkonen, both on a different strategy and still to stop.
At the top of the field, Schumacher continued to open the gap to Button: by lap 20 the German was over 12 seconds ahead, with the Briton himself also running a lonely race as Montoya had dropped back and was 14 seconds adrift of the BAR. For some time, Ralf came under pressure from Barrichello until he managed to get some breathing space when the Brazilian realised there was no way to overtake him on track.
Further back, the battle for the last point was over when Fisichella and Raikkonen finally made their first stops around lap 20, leaving Sato on his own. Montoya was again the first on the top runners to make his second pitstop, the Colombian retaining third place. Button and then Schumacher followed, and so did the rest of the field.
At the end of the second round of stops, the order remained unchanged except for Ralf, who was in fourth place having passed Trulli. The German quickly opened a gap to the Italian, who was caught by Barrichello and Alonso and followed for several laps. Neither the Brazilian not the Spaniard could do anything to pass, however.
The following laps went by action-less, until the final round of pitstops was triggered again by Montoya, who looked set for a lonely third place. Button, over 24 seconds behind Schumacher, pitted next, while the German followed suit two laps later.
Trulli stayed out a bit longer than Barrichello, and after a pitstop of 6.3 seconds, the Italian returned to the track in fifth place ahead of the Brazilian. Alonso, however, made the most of his second stint, the Spaniard pitting on lap 48. A couple of laps pushing at the limit, followed by a perfect pitstop from his Renault crew, saw Alonso emerging ahead of both Trulli and Barrichello.
It was a sensational move from the team, and one which allowed Alonso to get away from his teammate and set his sights on Ralf. The Renault driver needed just two laps to catch the German and, on lap 50, Alonso dived down the inside at Tosa. With his car almost ahead of Ralf, the German decided to close the door and they clashed, the Williams spinning.
Alonso continued in fourth, while Ralf dropped down to seventh ahead of Sato, although the Japanese driver's race would not last much longer, his Honda engine letting go with five laps remaining. That allowed Raikkonen to climb back to eighth and into the point-scoring positions.
While Schumacher and Button continued cruising home, Montoya began to come under pressure from Alonso, who closed a gap of over six seconds to get right behind the Colombian with three laps to go. As it was the case during most of the race, however, overtaking was a different matter and Alonso had to settle for fourth.
Schumacher nursed his Ferrari home, allowing Button to finish less then ten seconds behind, although the real gap was much more than that. "I had quite a gap and I saw Jenson's pace and just drove the race accordingly and eased off," said Schumacher, now leading the Championship by over 16 points over Barrichello and 17 over Button, who celebrated his and BAR's best ever result up to date.
The result suggested Button could be soon savoring the glory of victory, and with the Spanish Grand Prix coming up, the Briton will have another chance to shine at a track where BAR have flown in testing. Schumacher, however, has won there for the last three years and he will be the man to beat again.
"We might be closer," Button reflected after the race, "but to beat them is a big step forward."
Lap 1: At the start Button makes a good getaway and leads into the first corner. Michael Schumacher is second. Juan Pablo Montoya is slower away but Ralf Schumacher cannot pass him. The bunching in the midfield results in David Coulthard running into the back of Fernando Alonso and going off. He rejoins at the back and heads for the pits. At Tosa Montoya tries to drive around the outside of Michael Schumacher. The Williams is squeezed off the track and loses momentum. Ralf Schumacher tries to pass Montoya on the run up the hill towards Piratella but ran out of road and ended up on the grass and lost fourth place to Takuma Sato. All this leaves Button with a big lead from Michael Schumacher, Montoya, Sato, Ralf Schumacher, Rubens Barrichello, Jarno Trulli, Mark Webber, Fernando Alonso and Cristiano da Matta. Coulthard pits and rejoins a long way behind.
Lap 2: Schumacher begins to claw back the gap to Button and reduces the gap from 2.7 seconds to 2.1s. Montoya cannot keep up and is already 1.7s down on Schumacher. Further back Felipe Massa passes Olivier Panis for 11th place.
Lap 3: Schumacher takes another seven-tenths off Button’s lead.
Lap 4: Michael Schumacher is right behind Button but obviously cannot overtake unless Button makes a mistake. At the back of the field, Coulthard goes for a ride over the chicane.
Lap 7: The pit stops begin with da Matta and Massa stopping. This drops the pair from 10th and 11th to 15th and 14th, Massa having made a faster stop. While this is going on, Giorgio Pantano goes off and retires. Giancarlo Fisichella has a couple of minor offs.
Lap 8: Montoya is the first frontrunner to stop. He is followed into the pits by Mark Webber
Lap 9: Button stops and Schumacher immediately speeds up. Ralf Schumacher also stops. Panis and Christian Klien also pit.
Lap 10: The shuffling continues with Schumacher setting a very quick lap while behind him Sato and Barrichello both pit.
Lap 11: Schumacher pits but he has made up enough ground to emerge ahead of Button. Alonso also stops, leaving Trulli in second place for a lap.
Lap 12: Trulli is the last man to stop and so the new order emerges with Michael Schumacher ahead of Button, Montoya, Trulli, Ralf Schumacher, Barrichello, Alonso and Sato.
Lap 14: Heidfeld stops for the first stop.
Lap 16: The order is the same but Michael Schumacher’s lead is up to 10secs. Down at the back David Coulthard passes Klien for 16th position.
Lap 17: Heidfeld has a big spin but stays in 15th place.
Lap 19: Massa passes Webber for 11th place. It is clear that the Jaguar has some kind of a misfire. Coulthard stops having switched to a two-stop strategy.
Lap 20: Fisichella is ninth having gone without a stop. He drops to 14th place.
Lap 21: Raikkonen is also on a two-stop strategy and is up to ninth when he stops. He rejoins 14th.
Lap 23: Da Matta has his second pit stop and falls from 11th to 14th.
Lap 24: Massa and Webber have their second pit stops.
Lap 25: Montoya is the first frontrunner to stop. He falls back from third to seventh. Trulli moves up to third.
Lap 26: Button stops but he holds on to second place.
Lap 27: Michael Schumacher stops but he is able to rejoin his lead now around 18secs.
Lap 28: Ralf Schumacher and Barrichello stop again and that puts Alonso up to fourth place. Sato also stops but holds on to eighth place.
Lap 30: Alonso stops and so Montoya and Ralf Schumacher move up to fourth and fifth.
Lap 31: Trulli stops and so Montoya is back to third place with Ralf fourth, Trulli fifth, Barrichello sixth, Alonso seventh and Sato eighth.
Lap 32: Da Matta heads to the pits for a drive-through penalty, for ignoring blue flags. He rejoins the track but goes off almost immediately.
Lap 38: Little has changed. In the midfield the two Saubers both pit: Fisichella for the second time and Massa for the third time.
Lap 40: Coulthard, another two-stopper, pits but he is too far back to move up the order. He is 14th.
Lap 43: The third round of stops has changed little in the midfield. On lap 43 Montoya is the first frontrunner to stop for the last time. This puts Ralf third for a lap.
Lap 44: Button and Ralf Schumacher both stop. Button is still second but Trulli moves to third place. Alonso is fourth and Montoya fifth but it is clear that the Renaults must stop again.
Lap 46: Michael Schumacher and Trulli both stop. Schumacher stays ahead but Trulli falls behind Alonso, Montoya and Ralf. But he is ahead of Barrichello.
Lap 48: Alonso stops and so Montoya is back to third with Ralf fourth. Alonso is ahead of Trulli and challenging the Williams-BMW.
Lap 49: Nick Heidfeld goes out with a mechanical failure.
Lap 50: Alonso tries to pass Ralf Schumacher on the inside and has the inside line. Ralf then tried to close the gap, leaving Alonso nowhere to go. The two cars collide and Ralf spins. He drops to seventh place.
Lap 57: Eighth-placed Sato goes out with a big engine blow-up. This puts Raikkonen up to eighth but he is under pressure from Fisichella.
Lap 62: Michael Schumacher wins the race with Button second. Montoya holds off a challenge from Alonso to take third. Behind them Trulli holds off an attack from Barrichello for fifth and Raikkonen is able to stay ahead of Fisichella. Even further back Panis and Coulthard fight for 11th all the way to the flag.
© 2007 autosport.com
. This service is provided under the Atlas F1 terms and conditions.
Please Contact Us for permission to republish this or any other material from Atlas F1. |