The Bookworm Critique
By Mark Glendenning, Australia
Atlas F1 Columnist KEN TYRRELL:
There is something intrinsic in the nature of sport, and perhaps motorsport in particular, that makes it a fertile breeding ground for unbelievably intelligent, colourful, and gifted individuals, and few Formula One identities could demonstrate these qualities (and many others) in as large doses as did Tyrrell. The no-nonsense English team-owner steered his eponymous outfit through nearly four decades of racing, and weathered the full spectrum of experiences that only F1 can create.
There were the highs, of which Tyrrell's special relationship with Jackie Stewart is an obvious standout. The two of them formed a team boss/driver pairing of a kind rarely seen in Grand prix racing over the years – Chapman/Clark, Dennis/Hakkinen, perhaps Todt/Schumacher, maybe one or two others. In Tyrell's case, the reward was three World Championships at the hands of Sir Jackie, and if that's not worth writing a book about then I don't know what is.
But that's really just the tip of the iceberg. There was Project 34 – the infamous six-wheeler that almost turned Grand Prix racing on its head. Then there were the more difficult moments – the deaths of Francois Cevert and Stefan Bellof, and the eventual sale of the team that led to the birth of BAR. Throw Tyrrell himself into the mix, and suddenly you're struggling to think of reasons not to read it.
This book, a cousin of Karl Ludvigsen's Haynes driver biography series, sees Hilton draw heavily upon his own conversations with Tyrrell through the years, as well as the words of those who were on the scene during various critical moments of the team's existence.
The result is a fascinating glimpse of a man with the 'old guard' spirit of a true racer, a breed that has been hunted almost to extinction among the rows of palatial motorhomes in a Grand Prix paddock. (Although surviving examples can still be found in the form of Frank Williams and Patrick Head).
I'm of the wrong generation to have seen the Tyrrell team at the height of its power, and while I was aware of their various achievements, it took this book to draw an assortment of random facts and statistics and weave them into a single, flowing tale.
The real strength, however, lies in the accounts of those who were on the spot. To hear from such folk is invariably interesting, but what really struck me in this particular book was just how passionate just about everyone seemed to be about both the team and Tyrrell himself.
It's normal for people to sound publicly enthusiastic about their team, particularly if things are going well, but this seemed somehow different. One particular quote, referring to a period when the team had entered what would prove to be a terminal decline, illustrates this quite nicely:
'We were all totally convinced that we had the people to do it. Everyone was behind Ken and we were privileged to be working there as opposed to the other teams, because they were becoming big business. We almost judged that that wasn't racing anymore. Yes, it was going to be a struggle but we did feel all we needed was the engine. The morale at the team was fantastic.'" (p. 121)
The book does not escape without a few hiccups. One or two typos appear to have snuck past the proofreader, but of greater disappointment to me was that irrespective of what the dust jacket tries to tell you, I couldn't help feeling that the focus of the book sometimes swung too far toward Tyrrell the team, rather than Tyrrell the man.
There were also some loose ends that were never tied up. Toward the end of the book, for example, there are a few references to the Honda F1 project that was led by Harvey Postlethwaite, who was Tyrrell's last design chief. We are told that Postlethwaite took numerous Tyrrell staff with him to the Honda project following the Tyrrell team's demise, but we are not told that the Honda project was fated to be stillborn following Postlethwaite's sadly premature death.
One could argue that such detail is not necessarily of primary relevance to this book, but I believe that it at the very least warranted a footnote. Given that Hilton is far from shy when it comes to footnotes, the omission of this element of the story really surprised me.
On a similar note, the book seems to speed up as the story becomes more and more recent, to the point where the swansong years of the team pass in a blur. This is a shame, because the backdrop of the team's slow and sad descent into oblivion created an excellent opportunity for Hilton to present another side of Tyrrell's character that ultimately has gone begging. What did Ken really think about the state of the team in those final years? This book doesn't tell us.
There is certainly a brand of superficiality hanging over this book that might render some of the more seasoned historians out there a little wary, but even they will find something of value amongst the interview material contained between the covers. Otherwise, there is little to complain about.
The book is very well laid out and features some fabulous photographs that are further flattered by the use of matt paper. More than any other of Hilton's book that I have read, this one seems to really have come from the heart and Hilton has risen to the occasion. It's a pleasing account of a man whose story most certainly deserves to be told – and from an author that I wasn't expecting to enjoy. Sometimes, it's nice to be proven wrong.
© 2007 autosport.com
. This service is provided under the Atlas F1 terms and conditions.
Please Contact Us for permission to republish this or any other material from Atlas F1. |
|